Department of Medical and Surgical Sciences, University of Bologna, Bologna, Italy.
Department of Public Health, Erasmus Medical Center, Rotterdam, Netherlands.
Heart. 2020 Jan;106(1):40-49. doi: 10.1136/heartjnl-2019-315129. Epub 2019 Aug 22.
To assess whether recent declines in cardiovascular mortality have benefited all socioeconomic groups equally and whether these declines have narrowed or widened inequalities in cardiovascular mortality in Europe.
In this prospective registry-based study, we determined changes in cardiovascular mortality between the 1990s and the early 2010s in 12 European populations by gender, educational level and occupational class. In order to quantify changes in the magnitude of differences in mortality, we calculated both ratio measures of relative inequalities and difference measures of absolute inequalities.
Cardiovascular mortality has declined rapidly among lower and higher socioeconomic groups. Relative declines (%) were faster among higher socioeconomic groups; absolute declines (deaths per 100 000 person-years) were almost uniformly larger among lower socioeconomic groups. Therefore, although relative inequalities increased over time, absolute inequalities often declined substantially on all measures used. Similar trends were seen for ischaemic heart disease and cerebrovascular disease mortality separately. Best performer was England and Wales, which combined large declines in cardiovascular mortality with large reductions in absolute inequalities and stability in relative inequalities in both genders. In the early 2010s, inequalities in cardiovascular mortality were smallest in Southern Europe, of intermediate magnitude in Northern and Western Europe and largest in Central-Eastern European and Baltic countries.
Lower socioeconomic groups have experienced remarkable declines in cardiovascular mortality rates over the last 25 years, and trends in inequalities can be qualified as favourable overall. Nevertheless, further reducing inequalities remains an important challenge for European health systems and policies.
评估心血管死亡率的近期下降是否使所有社会经济群体同等受益,以及这些下降是否缩小或扩大了欧洲心血管死亡率的不平等。
在这项基于前瞻性登记的研究中,我们按性别、教育程度和职业阶层,确定了 12 个欧洲人群中心血管死亡率在 20 世纪 90 年代至 21 世纪初的变化。为了量化死亡率差异幅度变化的情况,我们计算了相对不平等的比率衡量指标和绝对不平等的差异衡量指标。
较低和较高社会经济群体中心血管死亡率迅速下降。较高社会经济群体的相对下降幅度更快;较低社会经济群体的绝对下降幅度(每 100000 人年死亡人数)几乎普遍更大。因此,尽管相对不平等随着时间的推移而增加,但所有使用的衡量指标的绝对不平等通常都大幅下降。单独来看,缺血性心脏病和脑血管病死亡率也呈现出类似的趋势。表现最好的是英格兰和威尔士,它在心血管死亡率大幅下降的同时,在两性中绝对不平等大幅减少,相对不平等保持稳定。在 21 世纪初,心血管死亡率的不平等在南欧最小,在北欧和西欧中等,在中东欧和波罗的海国家最大。
较低社会经济群体在过去 25 年中经历了心血管死亡率的显著下降,不平等趋势总体上是有利的。然而,进一步减少不平等仍然是欧洲卫生系统和政策的一个重要挑战。