Allen Heidi, Wright Bill J, Vartanian Keri, Dulacki Kristen, Li Hsin-Fang
Columbia University School of Social Work, NY (H.A.).
Center for Outcomes Research and Education (CORE), Providence Health & Services, Portland, OR (B.J.W., K.V., K.D.).
Circ Cardiovasc Qual Outcomes. 2019 Sep;12(9):e004391. doi: 10.1161/CIRCOUTCOMES.117.004391. Epub 2019 Aug 27.
Adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) are linked to poor adult health outcomes, including cardiovascular disease. However, little is known about its prevalence, specifically in low-income populations. The objective of this study was to estimate the extent of ACEs in a low-income, nonclinical, uninsured adult population and assess the relationship between ACEs and cardiovascular disease risk factors.
This study leverages the OHIE's (Oregon Health Insurance Experiment) study population, uninsured adults who were randomly selected to apply for Medicaid, and data collected through in-person health screenings. We objectively measured obesity, cholesterol, blood pressure, and blood sugar. Smoking, physical activity, and history of chronic disease were self-reported. Independent variables were the 10-item ACEs questions covering neglect, abuse, and household dysfunction. The sample consisted of 12 229 low-income, nonelderly uninsured adults who participated in the OHIE health screenings from 2009 to 2010. A total of 5929 (48%) returned a follow-up survey reporting ACEs in 2012. ACEs were more prevalent in low-income adults compared with previous estimates in a general clinical population, with notably high rates of emotional abuse, emotional neglect, and household dysfunction. ACEs were statistically associated with higher rates of obesity, smoking, and physical inactivity, but not high cholesterol or diabetes mellitus. We detected a strong relationship between ACEs and a self-reported history of a hypertension diagnosis but no statistically significant differences in being hypertensive.
This study design allowed us to assess the prevalence of ACEs among uninsured low-income adults and the association between ACEs and clinical indicators of cardiovascular disease risk that are difficult to ordinarily observe. Low-income adults have high rates of ACEs than previous prevalence estimates and ACEs were associated with higher rates of multiple cardiovascular disease risk factors. As states continue to expand Medicaid to the previously uninsured, providers may want to consider incorporating trauma-based approaches to care delivery.
童年不良经历(ACEs)与成年人不良健康结局相关,包括心血管疾病。然而,对其患病率了解甚少,尤其是在低收入人群中。本研究的目的是估计低收入、非临床、未参保成年人群中ACEs的程度,并评估ACEs与心血管疾病危险因素之间的关系。
本研究利用俄勒冈健康保险实验(OHIE)的研究人群,即随机选择申请医疗补助的未参保成年人,以及通过面对面健康筛查收集的数据。我们客观测量了肥胖、胆固醇、血压和血糖。吸烟、身体活动和慢性病病史通过自我报告获得。自变量是涵盖忽视、虐待和家庭功能障碍的10项ACEs问题。样本包括2009年至2010年参加OHIE健康筛查的12229名低收入、非老年未参保成年人。2012年,共有5929人(48%)返回了一份报告ACEs的随访调查。与之前一般临床人群的估计相比,ACEs在低收入成年人中更为普遍,尤其是情感虐待、情感忽视和家庭功能障碍的发生率很高。ACEs在统计学上与肥胖、吸烟和身体不活动的发生率较高相关,但与高胆固醇或糖尿病无关。我们发现ACEs与自我报告的高血压诊断史之间存在密切关系,但在高血压方面没有统计学上的显著差异。
本研究设计使我们能够评估未参保低收入成年人中ACEs的患病率,以及ACEs与通常难以观察到的心血管疾病风险临床指标之间的关联。低收入成年人的ACEs发生率高于之前的患病率估计,且ACEs与多种心血管疾病危险因素的较高发生率相关。随着各州继续将医疗补助扩大到以前未参保的人群,医疗服务提供者可能需要考虑采用基于创伤的护理方法。