Capital Medical University, No. 10 Xitoutiao, You An Men Wai, Fengtai District, Beijing, PR China 100069.
Human Development Research Foundation, F-7 Markaz, Islamabad, Pakistan.
Compr Psychiatry. 2019 Oct;94:152119. doi: 10.1016/j.comppsych.2019.152119. Epub 2019 Aug 21.
Gender disparity has been documented in advanced doctoral degrees, research, and academic positions, and therefore, it can logically be deduced that the gender disparity would be found in journals' editorial boards. In this study, we sought to determine the gender distribution in editorial boards of psychiatry journals worldwide. We also studied the academic achievements of editorial board members by comparing professional background, education level, and research productivity indices. We analyzed the gender of editorial members of 119 psychiatry journals from Clarivate Analytics' Journal Citation Reports. Our data included 8423 editorial board members from which we randomly selected 10% editorial board members to represent the full sample for further analyses. Overall, women represented 30.4% of editorial board and approximately 30% in each category: (1) Editor-in-chief/deputies, (2) Associate/section editors, (3) Editorial board*, and (4) Advisory board. The majority (65%) of men were M.D. psychiatrists, and women (58%) were Ph.D. psychologists. Women in editorial leadership positions (Category 1 & 2) were correlated with fewer women in editorial or advisory boards. Women had half the mean number of publications than men while serving journals with approximately the same mean impact factor. Our study results show that, besides gender disparity, gender bias does not exist in the psychiatry journal editorial boards. Given the implication of the editorial board position on science, academic advancement, and networking, this disparity remains detrimental to achieving equity, diversity, and inclusion in academic psychiatry.
性别差异在高级博士学位、研究和学术职位中都有记录,因此,可以合理地推断,这种性别差异也会存在于期刊的编辑委员会中。在这项研究中,我们试图确定全球精神病学期刊编辑委员会的性别分布。我们还通过比较专业背景、教育水平和研究生产力指标来研究编辑委员会成员的学术成就。我们分析了科睿唯安期刊引证报告中的 119 种精神病学期刊的编辑成员的性别。我们的数据包括来自 8423 名编辑委员会成员的信息,我们从中随机抽取了 10%的编辑委员会成员作为全样本的代表进行进一步分析。总体而言,女性占编辑委员会的 30.4%,在每个类别中约占 30%:(1)主编/副主任,(2)副主编/分部编辑,(3)编辑委员会*,和(4)顾问委员会。大多数(65%)男性是医学博士精神病学家,而女性(58%)是博士心理学家。担任编辑领导职务(类别 1 和 2)的女性与编辑或顾问委员会中女性的比例较低有关。在担任期刊编辑期间,女性的平均出版物数量比男性少一半,而这些期刊的平均影响因子大致相同。我们的研究结果表明,除了性别差异之外,精神病学期刊编辑委员会中不存在性别偏见。考虑到编辑委员会职位对科学、学术进步和网络的影响,这种差异仍然不利于实现学术精神病学中的公平、多样性和包容性。