Division of Unintentional Injury Prevention, National Center for Injury Prevention and Control, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia.
J Head Trauma Rehabil. 2020 Mar/Apr;35(2):E136-E143. doi: 10.1097/HTR.0000000000000534.
Because of limitations in current national data sets, respondent self-report may be critical to obtaining concussion prevalence estimates. We examined whether self-report of lifetime concussion among adults varies with the provision of a concussion definition and by the content of that definition.
A convenience sample of 6427 American adults who participated in the 2018 Porter Novelli SpringStyles survey.
Cross-sectional.
Frequency of self-reported concussion by variation in concussion definition.
A quarter of respondents (28.9%) reported experiencing a concussion in their lifetime. While concussion prevalence varied by demographic characteristics, it did not vary significantly by concussion definition. Variation in concussion definition did not result in differences related to recency of last concussion, mechanism of injury, or respondent activity engaged in during which they sustained their most recent concussion.
The current study suggested that in this sample of adults, the percentage reporting a concussion did not significantly vary by whether a concussion definition was provided or by the content of the definition. However, research suggests that prompting about mechanism of injury, listing symptoms individually, and considering only athletic populations may affect estimates and these factors should be included in future question comparisons.
由于当前国家数据集的限制,受访者的自我报告对于获得脑震荡患病率估计可能至关重要。我们研究了成年人一生中报告脑震荡的自我报告是否会因提供脑震荡定义以及该定义的内容而有所不同。
本研究采用便利抽样法,选取了 2018 年 Porter Novelli SpringStyles 调查中的 6427 名美国成年人作为研究对象。
横断面研究。
根据脑震荡定义的变化,报告脑震荡的频率。
四分之一的受访者(28.9%)报告在他们的一生中经历过脑震荡。虽然脑震荡的患病率因人口统计学特征而异,但与脑震荡定义并无显著差异。脑震荡定义的变化并未导致最近一次脑震荡、受伤机制或受访者在最近一次脑震荡期间从事的活动的差异。
本研究表明,在该成年人样本中,报告脑震荡的比例并未因提供脑震荡定义或定义的内容而显著不同。然而,研究表明,提示受伤机制、逐一列出症状以及仅考虑运动人群可能会影响估计,这些因素应在未来的问题比较中加以考虑。