de la Hera Diego Pablo, Sigman Mariano, Calero Cecilia Ines
1Laboratorio de Neurociencia, Universidad Torcuato Di Tella, Buenos Aires, Argentina.
2Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas (CONICET), Buenos Aires, Argentina.
NPJ Sci Learn. 2019 Aug 28;4:12. doi: 10.1038/s41539-019-0051-3. eCollection 2019.
Throughout development, children undergo moments of abrupt conceptual transitions, often replacing intuitive knowledge with grounded scientific theories. This typically also creates a situation of social conflict, as different children may hold at the same time substantially different theories and explanations about the same phenomenon. The main objective of this work is to understand whether social interaction and exchange of arguments and reasoning may be a catalyzer for conceptual development. Dyads of 7-year-old children with different conceptual understanding of the Earth were asked to reach a consensus about its astronomic and geometric properties. Our results show that mere minutes of deliberation can result in substantial changes in children's conceptual representations, and moreover, that this transition was consistently in the direction of reasoned and scientific opinions. These results provide empirical evidence and suggest specific ways in which peer interaction can be used effectively to promote conceptual change in school settings, in a knowledge domain at the center of this era's post truth and science denial crisis.
在整个成长过程中,儿童会经历概念的突然转变,往往用基于科学的理论取代直观知识。这通常也会引发社会冲突,因为不同的儿童可能同时对同一现象持有截然不同的理论和解释。这项工作的主要目标是了解社会互动以及论据和推理的交流是否可能是概念发展的催化剂。我们要求对地球有着不同概念理解的7岁儿童组成对子,就地球的天文和几何属性达成共识。我们的研究结果表明,仅仅几分钟的思考就能使儿童的概念表征发生重大变化,而且这种转变始终朝着理性和科学观点的方向发展。这些结果提供了实证依据,并提出了具体方法,说明在这个处于后真相和科学否定危机核心的知识领域中,同伴互动可以如何有效地用于促进学校环境中的概念转变。