From the Division of Pediatric Neurology, Duke University Health System, Duke University School of Medicine, Durham NC.
Neurology. 2019 Sep 24;93(13):e1248-e1259. doi: 10.1212/WNL.0000000000008159. Epub 2019 Sep 4.
To report our experience and investigate 5 original hypotheses: (1) multiple types of epileptic seizures occur in alternating hemiplegia of childhood (AHC), and these can be the initial presentation; (2) epileptiform abnormalities often appear well after clinical seizures; (3) nonepileptic reduced awareness spells (RAS) occur frequently; (4) epilepsy is commonly drug resistant but may respond to vagal nerve stimulation (VNS); and (5) status epilepticus (SE) is common and is usually refractory and recurrent.
We analyzed a cohort of 51 consecutive patients with AHC.
Thirty-two of 51 patients had epilepsy: 18 focal seizures, frontal more frequently than temporal, and then posterior. Eleven had primary generalized seizures (tonic-clonic, myoclonic, and/or absence). Epileptic seizures preceded other AHC paroxysmal events in 8 (lag 5.63 ± 6.55 months; = 0.0365). In 7 of 32, initial EEGs were normal, with the first epileptiform EEG lagging behind by 3.53 ± 4.65 years ( = 0.0484). RAS occurred equally in patients with epilepsy (16 of 32) and patients without epilepsy (10 of 19, = 1.0). Twenty-eight patients had video-EEG; captured RAS showed no concomitant EEG changes. Nineteen patients (59%) were drug resistant. VNS resulted in >50% reduction in seizures in 5 of 6 ( < 0.04). Twelve patients (38%) had SE (9 of 12 multiple episodes), refractory/superrefractory in all ( < 0.001), and 4 of 12 had regression after SE.
Epilepsy in AHC can be focal or generalized. Epileptic seizures may be the first paroxysmal symptom. EEG may become epileptiform only on follow-up. Epilepsy, although frequently drug resistant, can respond to VNS. RAS are frequent and nonepileptic. SE often recurs and is usually refractory/superrefractory. Our observations are consistent with current data on AHC-ATP1A3 pathophysiology.
报告我们的经验并探讨 5 个原始假设:(1)儿童交替性偏瘫(AHC)中会出现多种类型的癫痫发作,这些发作可能是首发症状;(2)癫痫样异常通常在临床发作后很久才出现;(3)非癫痫性意识障碍发作(RAS)频繁发生;(4)癫痫通常对药物治疗耐药,但可能对迷走神经刺激(VNS)有反应;(5)癫痫持续状态(SE)很常见,通常是难治性和复发性的。
我们分析了 51 例连续 AHC 患者的队列。
51 例患者中有 32 例患有癫痫:18 例局灶性发作,以额叶较颞叶更常见,然后是枕叶。11 例患有原发性全面性发作(强直-阵挛、肌阵挛和/或失神)。癫痫发作在其他 AHC 发作性事件之前发生在 8 例(潜伏期 5.63±6.55 个月;=0.0365)。在 32 例中的 7 例中,初始 EEG 正常,首次出现癫痫样 EEG 的潜伏期为 3.53±4.65 年(=0.0484)。癫痫发作的 32 例患者中有 16 例(RAS)和无癫痫发作的 19 例患者(RAS)同样存在(=1.0)。28 例患者进行了视频-EEG;捕获的 RAS 显示无伴随 EEG 变化。19 例患者(59%)药物难治。VNS 使 6 例(5 例)中的 5 例癫痫发作减少了 >50%(<0.04)。12 例患者(38%)发生 SE(9 例为多次发作),均为难治性/超难治性(<0.001),12 例中有 4 例在 SE 后出现消退。
AHC 中的癫痫可以是局灶性或全面性的。癫痫发作可能是首发阵发性症状。EEG 可能仅在随访时出现癫痫样改变。尽管癫痫通常对药物治疗耐药,但可以对 VNS 有反应。RAS 很常见,而且是非癫痫性的。SE 常反复发作,通常为难治性/超难治性。我们的观察结果与 AHC-ATP1A3 病理生理学的当前数据一致。