School of Chemical Engineering , Nanjing University of Science and Technology , 200 Xiao Ling Wei , 210094 Nanjing , P. R. China.
Soft Matter and Functional Materials , Helmholtz-Zentrum Berlin für Materialien und Energie GmbH , 14109 Berlin , Germany.
J Phys Chem B. 2019 Oct 3;123(39):8222-8231. doi: 10.1021/acs.jpcb.9b07448. Epub 2019 Sep 18.
We present a comprehensive analysis of the energetics of the binding of lysozyme to dendritic polyglycerolsulfate (dPGS) in aqueous solution. This system is a perfect model for studying the interaction of proteins with polyelectrolytes. We discuss and model the free energy of binding Δ = - ln as the function of the two decisive variables, namely, the salt concentration and the temperature . The system lysozyme/dPGS exhibits a strong enthalpy-entropy compensation throughout the entire range of temperature, similar to the one observed for the interaction of DNA with various proteins. Following a suggestion of Dragan et al. [ , , 301], the free energy Δ can be split up into Δ = Δ + Δ, where Δ denotes the part due to counterion release, whereas Δ is the part obtained by extrapolation of Δ to 1 M salt concentration. Plots of dlog /dlog lead to perfectly straight lines that can be extrapolated to = 1 M in order to obtain Δ. Both Δ and Δ can be independently obtained by implicit solvent molecular dynamics simulations made up to salt concentrations of 1 M. Good agreement of the experiment and simulation within prescribed limits of error is found. Moreover, Δ is shown to be caused by direct unscreened electrostatic contacts or salt bridges between dPGS and lysozyme. Because Δ = -Δ where Δ is the entropy due to counterion release, the entire binding entropy Δ can be split up as Δ = Δ + Δ. Plots of the binding enthalpy Δ versus Δ lead to a perfect master curve for the system dPGS/lysozyme. These findings suggest that the strong enthalpy-entropy cancellation found for this system is an entirely nonelectrostatic phenomenon solely due to solvation or desolvation by water. Thus, the results obtained here on the model system dPGS and lysozyme are in full agreement with the conclusion drawn by Dragan et al. for the binding of DNA to various proteins.
我们对溶菌酶在水溶液中与树枝状聚甘油硫酸酯(dPGS)结合的能量进行了全面分析。该系统是研究蛋白质与聚电解质相互作用的理想模型。我们讨论并将结合自由能Δ=-ln 作为两个决定性变量,即盐浓度 和温度 的函数进行建模。在整个温度范围内,溶菌酶/dPGS 系统表现出强烈的焓熵补偿,类似于 DNA 与各种蛋白质相互作用时观察到的情况。受 Dragan 等人的建议[1,2,301],自由能Δ可以分解为Δ=Δ+Δ,其中Δ表示抗衡离子释放的部分,而Δ是通过将Δ外推到 1 M 盐浓度获得的部分。dlog /dlog 的图得到的是完全的直线,可以外推到 = 1 M 以获得 Δ。通过在 1 M 盐浓度下进行的隐式溶剂分子动力学模拟,可以独立获得 Δ和 Δ。在规定的误差范围内,实验和模拟之间存在很好的一致性。此外,Δ是由 dPGS 和溶菌酶之间的直接未屏蔽静电接触或盐桥引起的。由于 Δ=-Δ,其中 Δ是抗衡离子释放引起的熵,整个结合熵 Δ可以分解为 Δ=Δ+Δ。结合焓 Δ与 Δ的图得到了 dPGS/溶菌酶系统的完美主曲线。这些发现表明,该系统中发现的强焓熵抵消完全是一种非静电现象,仅归因于水的溶剂化或去溶剂化。因此,这里在模型系统 dPGS 和溶菌酶上获得的结果与 Dragan 等人得出的关于 DNA 与各种蛋白质结合的结论完全一致。