Mantica Guglielmo, Balzarini Federica, Dotta Federico, Rodriguez-Socarras Moises, Proietti Silvia, Giusti Guido, Oneto Francesco, Di Pierro Marco, Traverso Paolo, Terrone Carlo
Department of Urology, Policlinico San Martino Hospital, University of Genova, Genova, Italy.
Department of Urology, San Raffaele Turro Hospital, San Raffaele University, Milan, Italy.
Arab J Urol. 2019 Apr 24;17(3):243-248. doi: 10.1080/2090598X.2019.1596400. eCollection 2019.
: To evaluate if the use of a photographic handbook (PH) can be a useful tool to improve the detection of disorders during cystoscopy training, as several hands-on tools have been proposed to improve technical skills but very few aim to improve specificity and sensitivity. : Eight junior residents (JRs) were divided into two groups: Group A, comprised four JRs with previous limited experience of performing cystoscopies; and Group B, including four inexperienced JRs who were asked to study a specific PH before performing cystoscopies. The findings of the two groups were compared using the chi-squared test. : A total of 401 consecutive cystoscopies, of which 214 (53.4%) were performed by Group A and 187 (46.6%) by Group B, were considered. Group B showed superior ability in detecting uncommon findings (i.e., carcinoma , bullous oedema, interstitial cystitis, etc.) with 24/46 (52.2%) detected vs eight of 32 (25%) in Group A ( = 0.016). : The PH was a useful tool for improving identification of pathological conditions, which could be used to enhance hands-on simulator and practical tutored training. : CIS: carcinoma ; JR: junior resident; PH: photographic handbook; VR: virtual reality Classification: Stones/Endourology.
为评估使用摄影手册(PH)是否可作为一种有用工具,以在膀胱镜检查培训期间改善疾病检测,因为已提出多种实践工具来提高技术技能,但旨在提高特异性和敏感性的工具很少。8名初级住院医师(JR)被分为两组:A组,由4名之前膀胱镜检查经验有限的JR组成;B组,包括4名无经验的JR,他们在进行膀胱镜检查前被要求学习一本特定的PH。使用卡方检验比较两组的检查结果。共考虑了401例连续的膀胱镜检查,其中A组进行了214例(53.4%),B组进行了187例(46.6%)。B组在检测罕见发现(即癌、大疱性水肿、间质性膀胱炎等)方面表现出更强的能力,检测出24/46(52.2%),而A组为32例中的8例(25%)(P = 0.016)。PH是改善病理状况识别的有用工具,可用于加强实践模拟器和实践辅导培训。CIS:癌;JR:初级住院医师;PH:摄影手册;VR:虚拟现实分类:结石/腔内泌尿外科。