Willems Ruben, de Hosson Michèle, De Backer Julie, Annemans Lieven
Department of Public Health and Primary Care, Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium.
Department of Adult Congenital Cardiology, Ghent University Hospital, Ghent, Belgium.
Cardiol Young. 2019 Nov;29(11):1368-1374. doi: 10.1017/S1047951119002245. Epub 2019 Sep 6.
The growing adult congenital heart disease (CHD) population requires efficient healthcare organisation. It has been suggested that clinically appropriate care be provided for individual patients on the least complex level possible, in order to alleviate saturation of special care programmes.
Semi-structured interviews with 10 general and 10 adult CHD cardiologists were conducted to elucidate opinions on healthcare organisation in Belgium. A particular focus was placed on the potential role of general cardiologists. The software program NVivo 12 facilitated thematic analysis.
A discrepancy existed between how general cardiologists thought about congenital care and what adult CHD cardiologists considered the minimum knowledge required to adequately treat patients. Qualitative data were categorised under the following themes: knowledge dissemination, certification, (de)centralisation of care, the role of adult CHD cardiologists, the role of dedicated nurse specialists, and patient referral. It appeared to be pivotal to organise care in such a way that providing basic care locally does not impede the generation of sufficient patient volume, and to continue improving communications between different care levels when there is no referral back. Moreover, practical knowledge is best disseminated locally. Cardiologists' opinions on certification and on the role of dedicated nurse specialists were mixed.
On the basis of the results, we propose five recommendations for improving the provision of care to adults with CHD. A multidimensional approach to defining the role of different healthcare professionals, to improving communication channels, and to effectively sensitising healthcare professionals is needed to improve the organisation of care.
成年先天性心脏病(CHD)患者数量不断增加,这就需要高效的医疗保健组织。有人建议,应在尽可能低复杂度的层面为个体患者提供临床适宜的护理,以缓解专科护理项目的饱和状态。
对10名普通心脏病专家和10名成年CHD心脏病专家进行了半结构化访谈,以阐明对比利时医疗保健组织的看法。特别关注普通心脏病专家的潜在作用。软件程序NVivo 12辅助进行了主题分析。
普通心脏病专家对先天性心脏病护理的看法与成年CHD心脏病专家认为充分治疗患者所需的最低知识之间存在差异。定性数据分为以下主题:知识传播、认证、护理的(去)中心化、成年CHD心脏病专家的作用、专科护士专家的作用以及患者转诊。以这样一种方式组织护理似乎至关重要,即本地提供基本护理不会妨碍产生足够的患者数量,并且在没有转回转诊的情况下,不同护理层面之间的沟通要持续改善。此外,实践知识最好在本地传播。心脏病专家对认证和专科护士专家的作用看法不一。
基于这些结果,我们提出了五项改善成年CHD患者护理的建议。需要一种多维方法来界定不同医疗保健专业人员的作用、改善沟通渠道以及有效地提高医疗保健专业人员的认识,以改善护理组织。