College of Public Health, Temple University, Philadelphia, PA, USA.
J Racial Ethn Health Disparities. 2020 Feb;7(1):72-83. doi: 10.1007/s40615-019-00635-3. Epub 2019 Sep 6.
Asian Americans have substantial transplantation needs but have the lowest rates of organ donation in the USA. As the shortage of transplantable organs persists, the rate of deceased donation by Asian Americans has not kept pace with that of the general population. This report is a qualitative study of organ donation-related attitudes and beliefs of three Asian ethnic groups located in the greater Philadelphia metropolitan area: Chinese, Filipino, and Vietnamese Americans. Guided by a Community Advisory Board representing these groups, we conducted 9 focus groups with a total of 64 participants and subsequent thematic analyses. Six major themes emerged: (1) positive views about organ donation, (2) previous exposure to organ donation, (3) primacy of the family in decision making, (4) mistrust of the healthcare and donation systems, (5) religious and cultural beliefs concerning the body, and (6) isolation from mainstream American society. Although participants expressed commonalities and beliefs in line with other American racial and ethnic groups, we also identified unique beliefs, such as familial influence, religious and cultural concerns regarding body wholeness and the dead, and underlying reasons for medical mistrust, such as a belief in a black market. The study's findings challenge the dominant educational and awareness campaigns about organ donation decision making that focus on individual autonomy and overlook the need for incorporating the specific content and message delivery needs of Asian Americans. This study is the first to explore attitudes and knowledge about posthumous organ donation among US Asian American populations in at least a decade.
亚裔美国人有大量的移植需求,但在美国的器官捐献率最低。随着可供移植器官的短缺持续存在,亚裔美国人的死亡捐献率并没有跟上总人口的步伐。本报告是对位于大费城都会区的三个亚裔族群(中国人、菲律宾人和越南人)的器官捐献相关态度和信仰进行的定性研究:中国人、菲律宾人和越南人。在代表这些群体的社区咨询委员会的指导下,我们进行了 9 次焦点小组讨论,共有 64 名参与者,随后进行了主题分析。出现了 6 个主要主题:(1)对器官捐献的积极看法,(2)以前接触过器官捐献,(3)家庭在决策中的首要地位,(4)对医疗保健和捐献系统的不信任,(5)关于身体的宗教和文化信仰,以及(6)与主流美国社会隔绝。尽管参与者表达了与其他美国种族和族裔群体一致的观点和信仰,但我们也发现了一些独特的信仰,如家庭影响、宗教和文化对身体完整性和死者的关注,以及对医疗不信任的潜在原因,例如对黑市的信仰。这项研究的发现挑战了关于器官捐献决策的主导性教育和宣传活动,这些活动侧重于个人自主权,而忽略了需要纳入亚裔美国人的具体内容和信息传递需求。这项研究是至少十年来首次探索美国亚裔美国人对死后器官捐献的态度和知识。