Moon Young-Jin, Moon Hyun S, Kim Dong-Sub, Kim Jae-Man, Lee Joon-Kyu, Shim Woo-Hyun, Kim Sung-Hoon, Hwang Gyu-Sam, Choi Jae-Soon
Biosignal Analysis and Perioperative Outcome Research Laboratory, Department of Anesthesiology and Pain Medicine, Asan Medical Center, University of Ulsan College of Medicine, 88, Olympic-ro 43-gil, Songpa-gu, Seoul 05505, Korea.
Health Innovation Bigdata Center, Asan Institute for Lifesciences, 88, Olympic-ro 43-gil, Songpa-gu, Seoul 05505, Korea.
J Clin Med. 2019 Sep 9;8(9):1419. doi: 10.3390/jcm8091419.
Although the stroke volume (SV) estimation by arterial blood pressure has been widely used in clinical practice, its accuracy is questionable, especially during periods of hemodynamic instability. We aimed to create novel SV estimating model based on deep-learning (DL) method. A convolutional neural network was applied to estimate SV from arterial blood pressure waveform data recorded from liver transplantation (LT) surgeries. The model was trained using a gold standard referential SV measured via pulmonary artery thermodilution method. Merging a gold standard SV and corresponding 10.24 seconds of arterial blood pressure waveform as an input/output data set with 2-senconds of sliding overlap, 484,384 data sets from 34 LT surgeries were used for training and validation of DL model. The performance of DL model was evaluated by correlation and concordance analyses in another 491,353 data sets from 31 LT surgeries. We also evaluated the performance of pre-existing commercialized model (EV1000), and the performance results of DL model and EV1000 were compared. The DL model provided an acceptable performance throughout the surgery ( = 0.813, concordance rate = 74.15%). During the reperfusion phase, where the most severe hemodynamic instability occurred, DL model showed superior correlation (0.861; 95% Confidence Interval, (CI), 0.855-0.866 vs. 0.570; 95% CI, 0.556-0.584, < 0.001) and higher concordance rate (90.6% vs. 75.8%) over EV1000. In conclusion, the DL-based model was superior for estimating intraoperative SV and thus might guide physicians to precise intraoperative hemodynamic management. Moreover, the DL model seems to be particularly promising because it outperformed EV1000 in circumstance of rapid hemodynamic changes where physicians need most help.
尽管通过动脉血压估算每搏输出量(SV)已在临床实践中广泛应用,但其准确性存疑,尤其是在血流动力学不稳定期间。我们旨在基于深度学习(DL)方法创建新型SV估算模型。应用卷积神经网络从肝移植(LT)手术记录的动脉血压波形数据中估算SV。该模型使用通过肺动脉热稀释法测量的金标准参考SV进行训练。将金标准SV与相应的10.24秒动脉血压波形合并为输入/输出数据集,以2秒滑动重叠,来自34例LT手术的484,384个数据集用于DL模型的训练和验证。在来自31例LT手术的另外491,353个数据集中,通过相关性和一致性分析评估DL模型的性能。我们还评估了现有的商业化模型(EV1000)的性能,并比较了DL模型和EV1000的性能结果。DL模型在整个手术过程中表现出可接受的性能(相关系数=0.813,一致性率=74.15%)。在发生最严重血流动力学不稳定的再灌注阶段,DL模型显示出比EV1000更高的相关性(0.861;95%置信区间,(CI),0.855 - 0.866 vs. 0.570;95%CI,0.556 - 0.584,P<0.001)和更高的一致性率(90.6% vs. 75.8%)。总之,基于DL的模型在估算术中SV方面更具优势,因此可能指导医生进行精确的术中血流动力学管理。此外,DL模型似乎特别有前景,因为在医生最需要帮助的血流动力学快速变化情况下,它的表现优于EV1000。