College of Economics, Nihon University, Tokyo, Japan.
Population Research Institute, Nihon University, Tokyo, Japan.
J Am Geriatr Soc. 2020 Feb;68(2):354-361. doi: 10.1111/jgs.16163. Epub 2019 Sep 11.
To compare cognitive performance among Japanese and American persons, aged 68 years and older, using two nationally representative studies and to examine whether differences can be explained by differences in the distribution of risk factors or in their association with cognitive performance.
Nationally representative studies with harmonized collection of data on cognitive functioning.
Nihon University Japanese Longitudinal Study of Aging and the US Health and Retirement Study.
A total of 1953 Japanese adults and 2959 US adults, aged 68 years or older.
Episodic memory and arithmetic working memory are measured using immediate and delayed word recall and serial 7s.
Americans have higher scores on episodic memory than Japanese people (0.72 points on a 20-point scale); however, when education is controlled, American and Japanese people did not differ. Level of working memory was higher in Japan (0.36 on a 5-point scale) than in the United States, and the effect of education on working memory was stronger among Americans than Japanese people. There are no differences over the age of 85 years.
Even with large differences in educational attainment and a strong effect of education on cognitive functioning, the overall differences in cognitive functioning between the United States and Japan are modest. Differences in health appear to have little effect on national differences in cognition. J Am Geriatr Soc 68:354-361, 2020.
通过两项具有全国代表性的研究,比较 68 岁及以上的日本人和美国人的认知表现,并检验这些差异是否可以用风险因素的分布差异或它们与认知表现的关联差异来解释。
具有认知功能数据协调收集的全国代表性研究。
日本大学老龄化纵向研究和美国健康与退休研究。
共有 1953 名日本成年人和 2959 名美国成年人,年龄在 68 岁或以上。
使用即时和延迟单词回忆以及连续 7 测试来测量情景记忆和算术工作记忆。
美国人的情景记忆得分高于日本人(20 分制中高出 0.72 分);然而,在控制教育程度后,美国人和日本人之间没有差异。工作记忆水平在日本(5 分制中高出 0.36 分)高于美国,而教育对工作记忆的影响在美国比在日本更强。85 岁以上没有差异。
即使在教育程度存在较大差异且教育对认知功能有强烈影响的情况下,美国和日本之间认知功能的总体差异也不大。健康差异对国家间认知差异的影响似乎很小。美国老年医学会 68:354-361,2020。