Hammami Muhammad B, Pandit Pratik, Salamo Rebecca T, Odufalu Florence-Damilola, Schroeder Katie
Division of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, Saint Louis University School of Medicine, St. Louis, MO.
Department of Internal Medicine, Saint Louis University School of Medicine, St. Louis, MO.
Ochsner J. 2019 Fall;19(3):210-219. doi: 10.31486/toj.18.0086.
Although it is well established that patients with inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) are at increased risk of complicating diseases and vaccination-preventable infections, whether gastroenterologists (GIs) or primary care providers (PCPs) assume responsibility for these patients' health maintenance is not clear. We anonymously surveyed a convenience sample of 94 PCPs and 61 GIs at Saint Louis University School of Medicine in St. Louis, MO, about their practice and perception of the health maintenance and vaccination of patients with IBD. Response rates were 82% and 93% for GIs and PCPs, respectively. GIs were as likely as PCPs to screen for smoking (88% vs 89%) and were significantly less likely to screen for depression/anxiety (24% vs 54%) or to provide pertussis (14% vs 44%) or diphtheria (20% vs 48%) vaccines. GIs were significantly more likely than PCPs to assess for colonoscopy need (94% vs 80%); to screen for nonmelanoma skin cancer (62% vs 14%), melanoma (56% vs 7%), osteoporosis (72% vs 51%), or tuberculosis (94% vs 44%); to prescribe calcium/vitamin D (74% vs 53%); to perform nutritional assessment (78% vs 33%); or to provide hepatitis A (60% vs 39%) or hepatitis B (86% vs 56%) vaccines. GIs were as likely as PCPs (64% vs 75%) to perceive that PCPs should order vaccinations and significantly more likely to perceive that GIs should track vaccinations (58% vs 16%) and other health maintenance issues (90% vs 49%). We found positive associations between performing the various health maintenance and vaccination tasks and the perception of responsibility. Several health maintenance aspects are inadequately addressed by GIs and PCPs, in part because of conflicting perceptions of responsibility. Clear guidelines and better GI/PCP communication are required to ensure effective health maintenance for patients with IBD.
尽管炎症性肠病(IBD)患者发生并发症和可通过疫苗预防的感染的风险增加已得到充分证实,但胃肠病学家(GI)或初级保健提供者(PCP)谁应对这些患者的健康维护负责尚不清楚。我们对密苏里州圣路易斯市圣路易斯大学医学院的94名初级保健提供者和61名胃肠病学家进行了一项匿名便利抽样调查,了解他们对IBD患者健康维护和疫苗接种的实践及看法。胃肠病学家和初级保健提供者的回应率分别为82%和93%。胃肠病学家与初级保健提供者筛查吸烟情况的可能性相当(88%对89%),而筛查抑郁/焦虑的可能性显著较低(24%对54%),提供百日咳疫苗(14%对44%)或白喉疫苗(20%对48%)的可能性也显著较低。胃肠病学家比初级保健提供者评估结肠镜检查需求的可能性显著更高(94%对80%);筛查非黑色素瘤皮肤癌(62%对14%)、黑色素瘤(56%对7%)、骨质疏松症(72%对51%)或结核病(94%对44%)的可能性显著更高;开具钙/维生素D的可能性更高(74%对53%);进行营养评估的可能性更高(78%对33%);提供甲型肝炎疫苗(60%对39%)或乙型肝炎疫苗(86%对56%)的可能性更高。胃肠病学家与初级保健提供者一样(64%对75%)认为初级保健提供者应安排疫苗接种,且更有可能认为胃肠病学家应跟踪疫苗接种情况(58%对16%)和其他健康维护问题(90%对49%)。我们发现执行各种健康维护和疫苗接种任务与责任认知之间存在正相关。胃肠病学家和初级保健提供者对几个健康维护方面的处理不足,部分原因是责任认知存在冲突。需要明确的指导方针和更好的胃肠病学家/初级保健提供者沟通,以确保为IBD患者提供有效的健康维护。