Toronto General Hospital Research Institute, University Health Network, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Health Expect. 2020 Feb;23(1):106-114. doi: 10.1111/hex.12973. Epub 2019 Sep 18.
Patient-centred care (PCC) improves health-care experiences and outcomes. Women with ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS) and clinicians have reported communication difficulties. Little prior research has studied how to improve communication and PCC for DCIS.
This study explored how to achieve PCC for DCIS.
Canadian women treated for DCIS from five provinces participated in semi-structured focus groups based on a 6-domain cancer-specific PCC framework to discuss communication about DCIS. Data were analysed using constant comparative technique.
Thirty-five women aged 30 to 86 participated in five focus groups at five hospitals.
Women said their clinicians used multiple approaches for fostering a healing relationship; however, most described an absence of desired information or behaviour to exchange information, respond to emotions, manage uncertainty, make decisions and enable self-management. Most women were confused by terminology, offered little information about the risks of progression/recurrence, uninformed about treatment benefits and risks, frustrated with lack of engagement in decision making, given little information about follow-up plans or self-care advice, and received no acknowledgement or offer of emotional support.
By comparing the accounts of women with DCIS to a PCC framework, we identified limitations and inconsistencies in women's lived experience of communication about DCIS, and approaches by which clinicians can more consistently achieve PCC for DCIS. Future research should develop and evaluate informational tools to support PCC for DCIS.
以患者为中心的护理(PCC)可改善医疗保健体验和结果。患有导管原位癌(DCIS)的女性和临床医生报告说存在沟通困难。先前很少有研究探讨如何改善 DCIS 的沟通和 PCC。
本研究探讨了如何实现 DCIS 的 PCC。
来自五个省份的接受 DCIS 治疗的加拿大女性参加了基于 6 个癌症特定 PCC 框架的半结构化焦点小组,讨论有关 DCIS 的沟通。使用恒比技术对数据进行分析。
35 名年龄在 30 至 86 岁之间的女性参加了五个医院的五个焦点小组。
女性表示,其临床医生采用了多种方法来建立治愈关系;然而,大多数人表示缺乏所需的信息或行为来交流信息、回应情绪、管理不确定性、做出决策和实现自我管理。大多数女性对术语感到困惑,很少提供有关进展/复发风险的信息,对治疗的益处和风险一无所知,对缺乏参与决策感到沮丧,很少提供有关随访计划或自我护理建议的信息,也没有得到任何情绪支持的认可或提议。
通过将 DCIS 女性的描述与 PCC 框架进行比较,我们确定了女性对 DCIS 沟通的亲身体验中存在的局限性和不一致之处,以及临床医生可以更一致地实现 DCIS 的 PCC 的方法。未来的研究应开发和评估信息工具,以支持 DCIS 的 PCC。