Crellin Erin, McClaren Belinda, Nisselle Amy, Best Stephanie, Gaff Clara, Metcalfe Sylvia
Australian Genomics Health Alliance, Melbourne, VIC, Australia.
Genomics in Society, Murdoch Children's Research Institute, Melbourne, VIC, Australia.
Front Genet. 2019 Sep 11;10:789. doi: 10.3389/fgene.2019.00789. eCollection 2019.
Developing a competent workforce will be crucial to realizing the promise of genomic medicine. The preparedness of medical specialists without specific genetic qualifications to play a role in this workforce has long been questioned, prompting widespread calls for education across the spectrum of medical training. Adult learning theory indicates that for education to be effective, a perceived need to learn must first be established. Medical specialists have to perceive genomic medicine as relevant to their clinical practice. Here, we review what is currently known about medical specialists' perceptions of genomics, compare these findings to those from the genetics era, and identify areas for future research. Previous studies reveal that medical specialists' views on the clinical utility of genomic medicine are mixed and are often tempered by several concerns. Specialists generally perceive their confidence and understanding to be lacking; subsequently, they welcome additional educational support, although specific needs are rarely detailed. Similar findings from the genetics era suggest that these challenges are not necessarily new but on a different scale and relevant to more specialties as genomic applications expand. While existing strategies developed for genetic education and training may be suitable for genomic education and training, investigating the educational needs of a wider range of specialties is critically necessary to determine if tailored approaches are needed and, if so, to facilitate these. Other interventions are also required to address some of the additional challenges identified in this review, and we encourage readers to see education as part of a broader implementation strategy.
培养一支有能力的专业队伍对于实现基因组医学的前景至关重要。长期以来,没有特定基因资质的医学专家在这支队伍中发挥作用的准备情况一直受到质疑,这促使人们广泛呼吁在整个医学培训范围内开展教育。成人学习理论表明,要使教育有效,首先必须确立一种感知到的学习需求。医学专家必须将基因组医学视为与其临床实践相关。在此,我们回顾目前已知的医学专家对基因组学的看法,将这些发现与遗传学时代的发现进行比较,并确定未来研究的领域。先前的研究表明,医学专家对基因组医学临床效用的看法不一,且往往受到若干担忧的影响。专家们普遍认为自己缺乏信心和理解;随后,他们欢迎额外的教育支持,尽管很少详细说明具体需求。遗传学时代的类似发现表明,这些挑战不一定是新的,只是规模不同,且随着基因组应用的扩大,与更多专业相关。虽然为基因教育和培训制定的现有策略可能适用于基因组教育和培训,但至关重要的是要调查更广泛专业的教育需求,以确定是否需要量身定制的方法,如果需要,则推动这些方法的实施。还需要其他干预措施来应对本综述中确定的一些额外挑战,我们鼓励读者将教育视为更广泛实施策略的一部分。