Yale School of Medicine, Department of Psychiatry, United States; University of Akron, Department of Psychology, United States.
National Center for PTSD, Dissemination and Training Division, United States.
J Anxiety Disord. 2019 Dec;68:102120. doi: 10.1016/j.janxdis.2019.102120. Epub 2019 Oct 1.
Trauma-focused therapies, including Cognitive Processing Therapy (CPT; Resick et al., 2016), are effective at reducing clients' PTSD symptoms. A limitation to these treatments, however, is client completion of them. The current study examined temporal patterns of treatment non-completion and the relationships among non-completion, PTSD, and overall mental health functioning outcomes, among clients in a randomized controlled CPT implementation trial. Two models of symptom change were tested: 1) dose-effect model (i.e., clients uniformly improve with additional sessions at a negatively accelerating rate); and 2) the good-enough level model (i.e., clients remain in therapy until they have achieved sufficient improvement, thus clients who attend fewer sessions improve at quicker rates). Results indicated that 42% of clients did not complete treatment, with most discontinuing between sessions two and five. Data did not fit the dose-effect or good-enough level model. Rather, clients who improved at a greater rate in their PTSD symptoms and overall mental health functioning attended more sessions. The average client had the best outcomes when they completed all 12 sessions. Identifying clients who may be at risk for discontinuing treatment, and making a concerted effort toward retaining them, is imperative to reduce non-completion rates and ultimately improve client outcomes.
创伤为中心的治疗,包括认知加工疗法(CPT;Resick 等人,2016 年),可以有效地减少客户的 PTSD 症状。然而,这些治疗方法的一个局限性是客户完成治疗的情况。目前的研究检查了治疗不完成的时间模式,以及在随机对照 CPT 实施试验中,不完成治疗与 PTSD 和整体心理健康功能结果之间的关系。测试了两种症状变化模型:1)剂量效应模型(即,随着额外疗程的增加,客户以负加速率均匀改善);2)足够好的水平模型(即,客户继续治疗直到他们取得足够的改善,因此参加较少疗程的客户改善速度更快)。结果表明,42%的客户没有完成治疗,大多数客户在治疗的第 2 至第 5 次治疗之间停止治疗。数据不符合剂量效应或足够好的水平模型。相反,PTSD 症状和整体心理健康功能改善速度较快的客户参加了更多的疗程。当客户完成所有 12 个疗程时,平均客户的效果最佳。确定可能有中断治疗风险的客户,并集中精力留住他们,对于降低不完成率并最终改善客户结果至关重要。