RCSI Health Professions Education Centre, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, 123 St. Stephen's Green, Dublin 2, Dublin, Ireland.
BMC Med Educ. 2019 Oct 17;19(1):376. doi: 10.1186/s12909-019-1811-8.
The use of mobile devices such as tablets and laptops by students to support their learning is now ubiquitous. The clinical setting is an environment, which lends itself to the use of mobile devices as students are exposed to novel clinical scenarios that may require rapid location of information to address knowledge gaps. It is unknown what preferences students have for these devices and how they are used in the clinical environment.
In this study we explored medical students' choices and their use of different devices in their first year of clinical attachments. We sought to evaluate learners' experiences with these devices using a mixed methods approach. All students newly entered into the clinical years were given the option of a MacBook Air or iPad. We surveyed these students using an online survey tool followed by individual semi-structured interviews to explore survey findings in more depth.
Students owned a multitude of devices however their preferences were for the 11 in. MacBook Air Laptop over the iPad mini. Students made constant use of online information to support their clinical learning, however three major themes emerged from the interview data: connection and devices (diverse personal ownership of technology by students and how this is applied to source educational materials), influence and interaction with patients (use of any device in a clinical setting) and influence and interaction with staff. In general students preferred to use their device in the absence of patients however context had a significant influence.
These mobile devices were useful in the clinical setting by allowing access to online educational material. However, the presence of patients, and the behaviour of senior teaching staff significantly influenced their utilisation by students. Understanding the preferences of students for devices and how they use their preferred devices can help inform educational policy and maximise the learning from online educational content.
学生现在普遍使用平板电脑和笔记本电脑等移动设备来支持学习。临床环境适合使用移动设备,因为学生接触到新的临床场景,可能需要快速找到信息来解决知识空白。目前尚不清楚学生对这些设备的偏好是什么,以及它们在临床环境中是如何使用的。
在这项研究中,我们探讨了医学生在临床实习第一年的选择以及他们对不同设备的使用情况。我们试图使用混合方法评估学习者对这些设备的体验。所有新进入临床年的学生都可以选择 MacBook Air 或 iPad。我们使用在线调查工具对这些学生进行了调查,然后进行了个别半结构化访谈,以更深入地探讨调查结果。
学生拥有多种设备,但他们更喜欢 11 英寸 MacBook Air 笔记本电脑而不是 iPad mini。学生经常使用在线信息来支持他们的临床学习,但从访谈数据中出现了三个主要主题:连接和设备(学生个人拥有的技术种类繁多,以及如何将其应用于获取教育材料)、与患者的影响和互动(在临床环境中使用任何设备)以及与员工的影响和互动。总的来说,学生希望在没有患者的情况下使用他们的设备,但背景对他们的使用有重大影响。
这些移动设备在临床环境中很有用,因为它们允许访问在线教育材料。然而,患者的存在以及高级教学人员的行为对学生的使用有重大影响。了解学生对设备的偏好以及他们如何使用他们喜欢的设备,可以帮助制定教育政策,并最大限度地从在线教育内容中学习。