School of Science, Engineering & Environment, University of Salford, Salford M5 4WT, UK; Mahavir Cancer Sansthan and Research Center, Patna, India; Department of Environment and Water Management, A.N. College, Patna, India.
Mahavir Cancer Sansthan and Research Center, Patna, India; Department of Environment and Water Management, A.N. College, Patna, India; Aryabhatta Centre for Nanoscience and Nanotechnology, Aryabhatta Knowledge University, Patna, India.
Sci Total Environ. 2020 Feb 10;703:134774. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2019.134774. Epub 2019 Nov 2.
In arsenic (As) endemic areas of south-east Asia, where a subsistence rice-based diet is prevalent, As exposure from food is mainly focused on rice intake. However, consumption of wheat is substantial and increasing. We present a probabilistic assessment of increased cancer risk from wheat-based food intake in a study population of rural Bihar, India where As exposure is endemic. Total As in wheat grains (43.64 ± 48.19 µg/kg, n = 72) collected from 77 households across 19 villages was found to be lower than reported As in wheat grains from other south-east Asian countries but higher than a previous study from Bihar. This is the first study where As concentration in wheat flour was used for risk estimation, bearing in mind that it was the flour obtained after indigenous household processing of the grains that was used for making the home-made bread (chapati) which contributed 95% of wheat intake for the studied population. Interestingly, while 78% of the surveyed participants (n = 154) consumed rice every day, chapati was consumed every day by 99.5% of the participants. In contrast to previous studies, where As concentration in wheat grains was found to be lower than the flour due to the removal of the bran on grinding, we did not find any appreciable lowering of arsenic in the wheat flour (49.80 ± 74.08 µg/kg, n = 58), most likely due to external contamination during processing and grinding. Estimated gender adjusted excess lifetime cancer risk of 1.23 × 10 for the studied rural population of Bihar indicated risk higher than the 10-10 range, typically used by the USEPA as a threshold to guide regulatory values. Hence, our findings suggest As exposure from wheat-based food intake to be of concern not only in As endemic areas of rural Bihar but also in non-endemic areas with similar wheat-based diet due to public distribution of the wheat across India.
在东南亚砷(As)流行地区,人们以大米为主食,主要通过摄入大米来接触 As。然而,人们对小麦的消费也相当大且呈上升趋势。我们对印度比哈尔邦农村地区的一个研究人群进行了一项基于概率的评估,该地区存在 As 暴露,小麦摄入量增加会增加癌症风险。我们从 19 个村庄的 77 户家庭中采集了 72 份小麦谷物,发现总 As 含量(43.64±48.19µg/kg)低于其他东南亚国家报告的小麦谷物中 As 含量,但高于比哈尔邦之前的研究。这是首次使用小麦粉中的 As 浓度进行风险估计的研究,需要注意的是,用于制作自制面包(chapati)的面粉是家庭加工谷物后的产物,而 chapati 是研究人群中摄入小麦的 95%。有趣的是,尽管 78%的被调查参与者(n=154)每天都吃米饭,但 99.5%的参与者每天都吃 chapati。与之前的研究不同,由于在研磨过程中去除了麸皮,导致小麦谷物中的 As 浓度低于面粉中的 As 浓度,我们发现小麦粉中的 As 浓度并没有明显降低(49.80±74.08µg/kg,n=58),这很可能是由于加工和研磨过程中的外部污染。对于比哈尔邦农村地区的研究人群,性别调整后的终生癌症超额风险估计值为 1.23×10,表明风险高于 USEPA 通常用作监管值指导的 10-10 范围。因此,我们的研究结果表明,不仅在比哈尔邦的砷流行地区,而且在印度各地普遍供应小麦的非流行地区,通过摄入小麦类食物接触 As 也令人担忧。