PROTECT, INSERM U1141, Université de Paris, Paris, France.
Service de Neurologie Pédiatrique, AP-HP, Hôpital Universitaire Robert-Debré, 48, Boulevard Sérurier, 75935, Paris Cedex 19, France.
Drugs. 2019 Dec;79(18):1917-1935. doi: 10.1007/s40265-019-01223-9.
Rare diseases provide a challenge in the evaluation of new therapies. However, orphan drug development is of increasing interest because of the legislation enabling facilitated support by regulatory agencies through scientific advice, and the protection of the molecules with orphan designation. In the landscape of the rare epilepsies, very few syndromes, namely Dravet syndrome, Lennox-Gastaut syndrome and West syndrome, have been subject to orphan drug development. Despite orphan designations for rare epilepsies having dramatically increased in the past 10 years, the number of approved drugs remains limited and restricted to a handful of epilepsy syndromes. In this paper, we describe the current state of orphan drug development for rare epilepsies. We identified a large number of compounds currently under investigation, but mostly in the same rare epilepsy syndromes as in the past. A rationale for further development in rare epilepsies could be based on the match between the drug mechanisms of action and the knowledge of the causative gene mutation or by evidence from animal models. In case of the absence of strong pathophysiological hypotheses, exploratory/basket clinical studies could be helpful to identify a subpopulation that may benefit from the new drug. We provide some suggestions for future improvements in orphan drug development such as promoting paediatric drug investigations, better evaluation of the incidence and the prevalence, together with the natural history data, and the development of new primary outcomes.
罕见病在评估新疗法时带来了挑战。然而,由于立法允许监管机构通过科学咨询提供便利支持,并对孤儿药进行分子保护,孤儿药的开发越来越受到关注。在罕见性癫痫的领域中,只有少数综合征,即 Dravet 综合征、 Lennox-Gastaut 综合征和 West 综合征,已经进行了孤儿药的开发。尽管过去 10 年来罕见性癫痫的孤儿药认定数量显著增加,但获得批准的药物数量仍然有限,仅限于少数几种癫痫综合征。本文描述了目前罕见性癫痫孤儿药的开发状况。我们发现了大量正在研究中的化合物,但大多数仍集中在过去同样的罕见癫痫综合征中。进一步开发罕见性癫痫的理由可以基于药物作用机制与致病基因突变知识的匹配,或来自动物模型的证据。在缺乏强有力的病理生理学假说的情况下,探索性/篮子临床试验可以帮助确定可能受益于新药的亚人群。我们针对孤儿药开发的未来改进提出了一些建议,如促进儿科药物研究、更好地评估发病率和患病率以及自然病史数据,并开发新的主要结局。