Department for Educational Counselling, Caritasverband Kleve e.V ., Kleve, Germany.
School of Education, Communication & Language Sciences, Newcastle University , Newcastle upon Tyne, UK.
Clin Linguist Phon. 2020 Jul 2;34(7):671-691. doi: 10.1080/02699206.2019.1692076. Epub 2019 Nov 21.
The verb inflections of matched groups of German-speaking children with developmental language disorder (DLD) and phonological impairment (PI) were evaluated, and performance compared with age-matched and language-matched typically developing (TD) children (66 participants in total). An elicitation task for second- and third-person singular present tense inflections was used and spontaneous language samples were also analysed for present tense inflections. Errors resulting from the children's speech difficulties were excluded from the analysis. Evidence was found in the elicited data for delayed development in the DLD children, but no differences were found between this group and the TD group matched on language development. Both clinical groups made errors consistent with bare stem- and prosodic factors described in the literature. The children with PI, although scoring within normal limits on standardised tests of language, displayed difficulties with tense inflections that went beyond limitations imposed by their speech. This suggests there may be underlying difficulties in both phonological and grammatical domains for both clinical groups, and potential interaction between these domains. It is recommended that clinicians take account of this possibility when assessing and identifying children with DLD and with PI, and that they avoid reliance on standardised language tests or assessment of grammatical morphology alone when assessing for DLD.
对患有发育性语言障碍(DLD)和语音障碍(PI)的德语儿童进行了动词屈折变化的评估,并与年龄匹配和语言匹配的典型发育(TD)儿童(共 66 名参与者)进行了比较。使用了第二人称和第三人称单数现在时屈折的诱发任务,并且还分析了自然语言样本中的现在时屈折。从分析中排除了儿童言语困难导致的错误。诱发数据显示 DLD 儿童的发育延迟,但与在语言发育方面相匹配的 TD 组相比,没有发现差异。两个临床组都犯了与文献中描述的光秃词干和韵律因素一致的错误。尽管 PI 组的儿童在语言的标准化测试中得分在正常范围内,但他们在时态屈折方面存在困难,超出了他们言语所限制的范围。这表明这两个临床组可能在语音和语法领域都存在潜在的困难,并且这些领域之间可能存在相互作用。建议临床医生在评估和识别患有 DLD 和 PI 的儿童时考虑到这种可能性,并避免在评估 DLD 时仅依赖标准化语言测试或语法形态评估。