Hoshino Takashi, Tateishi Tomohiko, Nagase Tsuyoshi, Yuki Arata, Nakagawa Teruhiko, Tsuchiya Masamitsu
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Doai Memorial Hospital, 2-1-11 Yokoami, Sumida-ku, Tokyo 130-8587, Japan.
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Tokyo Medical and Dental University Hospital of Medicine, 1-5-45 Yushima, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo 113-8519, Japan.
Case Rep Orthop. 2019 Oct 24;2019:9051327. doi: 10.1155/2019/9051327. eCollection 2019.
Jones fractures sometimes occur in athletes and are known to have complications, such as nonunion, delayed union, and recurrence, even with treatment. We describe three cases of Jones fractures in sumo wrestlers with treatment-related difficulties. All patients discontinued treatment at their own discretion. The two conservative cases had nonunion or delayed union, and the operative case had a broken screw. However, all patients continued sumo wrestling, with little impact on their careers. The risk factors of Jones fractures in sumo wrestling may be heavy weight, and training or competition characteristics unique to sumo wrestling. In cases of a complete Jones fracture, operative treatment is most commonly selected, as the risk for nonunion or refractures is less than that for conservative treatment. However, in the case of sumo wrestlers, there are risks of infection and problems with treatment compliance. As taking a rest may result in a lowered rank, completing a sufficient duration of treatment is difficult. Treatment is difficult and controversial in sumo wrestlers; all three patients discontinued treatment of their own accord. These cases suggest that it is important to thoroughly inform sumo wrestlers of the treatment options, and to decide the most appropriate treatment method for each patient.
琼斯骨折有时会发生在运动员身上,并且已知即使经过治疗也会出现诸如骨不连、延迟愈合和复发等并发症。我们描述了三例相扑选手发生琼斯骨折且伴有治疗相关困难的病例。所有患者均自行决定停止治疗。两例采用保守治疗的患者出现了骨不连或延迟愈合,而接受手术治疗的患者出现了螺钉断裂。然而,所有患者都继续从事相扑运动,对其职业生涯影响不大。相扑运动中琼斯骨折的风险因素可能是体重过重以及相扑运动特有的训练或比赛特点。在琼斯骨折完全骨折的情况下,由于骨不连或再骨折的风险低于保守治疗,手术治疗是最常用的选择。然而,对于相扑选手而言,存在感染风险和治疗依从性问题。由于休息可能导致排名下降,因此很难完成足够疗程的治疗。相扑选手的治疗困难且存在争议;所有三名患者均自行停止了治疗。这些病例表明,必须向相扑选手充分告知治疗方案,并为每位患者确定最合适的治疗方法。