Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife, La Grande, OR, USA.
Wyoming Geographic Information Science Center, University of Wyoming, Laramie, WY, USA.
J Anim Ecol. 2020 Mar;89(3):757-771. doi: 10.1111/1365-2656.13159. Epub 2020 Jan 24.
The isotopic niche of consumers represents biologically relevant information on resource and habitat use. Several tools have been developed to quantify niche size and overlap. Nonetheless, methods adapted by spatial ecologists to quantify animal home ranges can be modified for use in stable isotope ecology when data are not normally distributed in bivariate space. We offer a tool that draws on existing spatial metrics, such as minimum convex polygon (MCP) and standard ellipse area (SEA), and add novel metrics using kernel utilization density (KUD) estimators to measure isotopic niche size and overlap. We present examples using empirical and simulated data to demonstrate the performance of the package kernel isotopic niches in r (rKIN) under various scenarios. Results of niche size from MCP, SEA and KUD were highly correlated but divergent among datasets. Overall, the KUD method produced the largest niche sizes and was more sensitive to the distribution of the isotopic data. Pairwise estimates of overlap were highly variable, likely because MCP and SEA inherently include or exclude unused areas in the resulting niche estimate. Four bandwidth methods (reference, normal scale, plug-in and biased cross-validation) produced comparable estimates of niche size and overlap at various sample sizes (10-40). Niche size and overlap were consistent across sample sizes >15. Use of rKIN will allow isotope ecologists to quantify niche shifts, expansions or contractions, as well as assess the performance of several estimation methods. The package also can be applied to other data types (e.g. principal component analysis, multi-dimensional scaling) so long as axes and measurement units are identical and can be converted to Cartesian coordinates.
消费者的同位素生态位代表了有关资源和栖息地利用的生物学相关信息。已经开发了几种工具来量化生态位的大小和重叠。尽管如此,空间生态学家用来量化动物栖息地范围的方法可以在数据在双变量空间中不是正态分布时进行修改,以用于稳定同位素生态学。我们提供了一种工具,该工具利用了现有的空间指标,例如最小凸多边形(MCP)和标准椭圆面积(SEA),并使用核利用密度(KUD)估计器添加了新的指标来测量同位素生态位的大小和重叠。我们使用经验数据和模拟数据示例展示了 rKIN 包在各种情况下的表现。MCP、SEA 和 KUD 的生态位大小结果高度相关,但数据集之间存在差异。总体而言,KUD 方法产生的生态位最大,并且对同位素数据的分布更为敏感。重叠的成对估计值高度可变,这可能是因为 MCP 和 SEA 在产生的生态位估计中固有地包含或排除了未使用的区域。四种带宽方法(参考、正态尺度、插补和有偏交叉验证)在各种样本量(10-40)下产生了相似的生态位大小和重叠估计值。在样本量>15 的情况下,生态位大小和重叠保持一致。rKIN 的使用将使同位素生态学家能够量化生态位的变化、扩张或收缩,并评估几种估计方法的性能。该包还可以应用于其他数据类型(例如主成分分析、多维缩放),只要轴和测量单位相同并且可以转换为笛卡尔坐标。