Centre for Research, Education, Innovation and Intervention in Sport (CIFI2D), Faculty of Sport, University of Porto, Portugal.
Auburn University, Auburn, Alabama, United States.
J Sports Sci Med. 2019 Nov 19;18(4):812-829. eCollection 2019 Dec.
The purpose of the present study was to conduct a review of the research on the Sport Education (SE) studies that have examined the development of students' personal and social skills. Research articles selected were found through Web of Science, SCOPUS, Academic Search Complete, ERIC, SPORTDiscus with Full Text, Education Source, PsycINFO and PsycARTICLES databases. The keywords "Sport Education" and "physical education" were used in different combinations. The articles were included for analysis if the following criteria were met: (i) were published in peer-reviewed international journals indexed in JCR (Journal Citation Reports) or SJR (Scientific Journal Rankings); (ii) were available in full-text; (iii) examined personal and social variables included or measured as main outcomes within the SE model. The quality of the selected studies was scored using a quality assessment list. Fifty-one studies were included. Results showed that, considering the development of social and personal competencies, the majority of SE research took place in Spain and USA in a co-educational PE context (high school). Enjoyment/satisfaction, enthusiasm and engagement were the predominant outcome measures, using a non-experimental design and multiple qualitative tools in more than half of the studies. Few studies established the fidelity of the model implementation. There is a need for future research to consider other samples, contexts, cultures and types of sports seeking to reinforce the positive impact of SE on the personal and social competencies. Longer units with a good planning, mixed and quantitative methodological designs and the report of the model fidelity would be also particularly important for future investigations.
本研究旨在对考察学生个人和社会技能发展的体育教育(Sport Education,SE)研究进行综述。通过 Web of Science、SCOPUS、Academic Search Complete、ERIC、SPORTDiscus with Full Text、Education Source、PsycINFO 和 PsycARTICLES 数据库,选择研究文章。使用了“Sport Education”和“physical education”的不同组合作为关键词。如果符合以下标准,则将文章纳入分析:(i)发表在同行评审的国际期刊上,这些期刊在 JCR(期刊引文报告)或 SJR(科学期刊排名)中被索引;(ii)全文可用;(iii)在 SE 模型中,考察个人和社会变量,这些变量被包括或作为主要结果进行测量。使用质量评估清单对选定研究的质量进行评分。共纳入 51 项研究。结果表明,考虑到社会和个人能力的发展,大多数 SE 研究在西班牙和美国的男女同校体育教育背景(高中)进行。享受/满意度、热情和投入是主要的结果衡量标准,超过一半的研究采用非实验设计和多种定性工具。很少有研究确定了模型实施的保真度。未来的研究需要考虑其他样本、背景、文化和运动类型,以加强 SE 对个人和社会能力的积极影响。更长的单元、良好的规划、混合和定量方法设计以及对模型保真度的报告,对未来的研究也将特别重要。