Scuola Universitaria Superiore IUSS Pavia, 27100 Pavia, Italy.
Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 2020 Feb 3;375(1791):20190310. doi: 10.1098/rstb.2019.0310. Epub 2019 Dec 16.
Predication is the fundamental grammatical relation defining clausal structures in all (and only) human languages. This notion is by definition compositional, since it consists of a link between a subject and a predicate. The central question addressed here is whether this traditional notion, which has never been dismissed ever since the canonical models of Ancient Greek linguistics, can be derived at a formal level from more abstract compositional algorithms. Capitalizing on predication in copular sentences, which allow factoring out non-essential aspects of this phenomenon, such as the morphological asymmetry between verbs and nouns, I propose a configurational approach to predication. This new approach is based on the notion of symmetry as derived by purely compositional mechanisms. Finally, I address some theoretical and empirical consequences of this generalization including those pertaining to neurolinguistics. This article is part of the theme issue 'Towards mechanistic models of meaning composition'.
预测是定义所有(且仅有的)人类语言中句子结构的基本语法关系。这个概念从定义上就是由组成的,因为它包含主语和谓语之间的联系。这里所讨论的核心问题是,这个传统概念自古希腊语言学的规范模型以来从未被摒弃过,是否可以从更抽象的组合算法中在形式层面推导出来。利用系动词句子中的谓语关系,从中可以提取出这个现象的非本质方面,例如动词和名词之间的形态不对称性,我提出了一种谓语关系的结构方法。这种新方法基于通过纯粹组合机制得出的对称概念。最后,我探讨了这个泛化的一些理论和经验后果,包括与神经语言学相关的后果。本文是主题为“迈向意义组合的机械模型”的一部分。