Anwar Muhammad Shakaib, Shakaib Baila, Akhtar Waseem, Yusufzai Erum, Zehra Maham, Munawar Hajira, Azhar Kinza
Department of Ophthalmology, Rawal Institute of Health and Sciences, Islamabad 44000, Pakistan.
Medical College, Rawal Institute of Health and Sciences, Islamabad 44000, Pakistan.
Int J Ophthalmol. 2019 Dec 18;12(12):1885-1892. doi: 10.18240/ijo.2019.12.11. eCollection 2019.
To assess the current knowledge and practices in diabetic eye care and referral system regarding diabetic retinopathy (DR) in health centers of Islamabad and Rawal-Pindi.
A cross-sectional study was carried out in 4 government and private health centers in Rawalpindi-Islamabad from May 2018 to Oct. 2018. A total of 38 Primary Care Physicians (general practitioners, family physicians, and internists) were recruited out of which data for 2 were either not returned, or were missing partially. Data were collected through a 27-item consented & validated, multiple-choice questionnaire based on physician characteristics, knowledge and practice of diabetic eye care and challenges faced due current DR referral system. Descriptive analyses for all variables were performed including, mean and standard deviation. Analytical analyses were also conducted to study association between different study variables.
Mean scores of knowledge for general practitioners, family physicians, and internists were 41.7%, 42.0% and 46.6% respectively. A lack of knowledge, and suboptimal practices were observed regarding signs, symptoms, screening, testing, evaluation and referral of DR regardless of physicians' specialty, or years in practice. Lack of expertise regarding direct ophthalmoscopy, interpretation of findings, and referral to an ophthalmologist were noted. Physicians who performed consultation and counselling according to patients' needs referred more patients to an ophthalmologist than those who restricted their consultation to a fixed amount of time and had more patients per unit time (=0.01). Physicians who had taken care of less than 5 number of patients with DR marked less incorrect answers with no significantly greater number or correct answers compared to physicians who had taken care of more than 5 number of patients with DR (=0.044). An association of more than 5 patients with DR taken care of with more need based patient consultation and counselling was also noted (=0.017). An evaluation of the current referral system for DR revealed major loopholes in the health care infrastructure, proper guidelines, properly functioning equipment, check and balances, and lack of guidance to physicians regarding acquiring and updating knowledge regarding DR.
Lack of updated and adequate knowledge, practices among primary care physicians, and suboptimal diabetic eye care and referral system have contributed to late presentation of DR. Interventions are needed to improve current diabetic eye care, and knowledge and practices of primary care physicians.
评估伊斯兰堡和拉瓦尔品第各健康中心在糖尿病眼病护理及糖尿病视网膜病变(DR)转诊系统方面的现有知识和实践情况。
2018年5月至10月在拉瓦尔品第 - 伊斯兰堡的4家政府和私立健康中心开展了一项横断面研究。共招募了38名初级保健医生(全科医生、家庭医生和内科医生),其中2人的数据未返回或部分缺失。通过一份基于医生特征、糖尿病眼病护理知识与实践以及当前DR转诊系统所面临挑战的、经同意且经验证的27项多项选择题问卷收集数据。对所有变量进行描述性分析,包括均值和标准差。还进行了分析性分析以研究不同研究变量之间的关联。
全科医生、家庭医生和内科医生的知识平均得分分别为41.7%、42.0%和46.6%。无论医生的专业或从业年限如何,在DR的体征、症状、筛查、检测、评估和转诊方面均存在知识欠缺和实践欠佳的情况。注意到在直接检眼镜检查、检查结果解读以及转诊至眼科医生方面缺乏专业知识。根据患者需求进行咨询和指导的医生比那些将咨询限制在固定时间且单位时间内患者更多的医生转诊给眼科医生的患者更多(=0.01)。与诊治过5例以上DR患者的医生相比,诊治过少于5例DR患者的医生答错的题目更少,但答对的题目数量没有显著增加(=0.044)。还发现诊治过5例以上DR患者与更多基于需求的患者咨询和指导之间存在关联(=0.017)。对当前DR转诊系统的评估显示,医疗基础设施、适当指南、正常运行的设备、制衡机制存在重大漏洞,并且在获取和更新DR知识方面缺乏对医生的指导。
初级保健医生缺乏最新且充分的知识和实践,以及糖尿病眼病护理和转诊系统欠佳,导致DR出现较晚。需要采取干预措施来改善当前的糖尿病眼病护理以及初级保健医生的知识和实践。