Department of Radiation Oncology, H. Lee Moffitt Cancer Center & Research Institute, 12902 Magnolia Drive, Tampa, FL, 33612, USA.
Department of Health Outcomes & Behavior, H. Lee Moffitt Cancer Center & Research Institute, Tampa, FL, USA.
Support Care Cancer. 2020 Sep;28(9):4141-4145. doi: 10.1007/s00520-019-05238-6. Epub 2019 Dec 24.
Patient perspectives of their symptom burden provide valuable data to clinicians. We have investigated the Edmonton Symptom Assessment Scale (ESAS) extensively in our radiation oncology and supportive care clinics. We were interested in examining whether ESAS data could correlate with anemia.
Our clinics have used a modified ESAS since 2015; patients now input data directly into the electronic medical record using a tablet interface. Of 9813 patients providing ESAS reports, we retrieved hemoglobin (Hb) data from 8304. Of these, 1351 patients had both performed on the same day. Anemia existed if Hb was < 13.0 g/L (man) or < 12 g/L (woman).
When self-reported scores for both tiredness and shortness of breath were 7 and above, the positive predictive value (PPV) for anemia was 80%, and specificity was 97.6%. Corresponding sensitivity was 8.2% and accuracy was 48.9%. This 2-item model could be a valuable screening tool for lack of anemia in cancer patients in the outpatient setting: if patients rate both these ESAS items < 7, there exists < 3% false positive risk. An expanded 5-item model adding lack of appetite, pain, and bone marrow primary site increased sensitivity and accuracy at the expense of specificity and PPV. We consider this less clinically functional than the two-item screen.
This is one of the first reports of PRO data screening for a clinical sign, in this case, anemia. Predicting freedom from anemia is feasible using 2 ESAS survey questions: tiredness and shortness of breath.
患者对自身症状负担的看法为临床医生提供了有价值的数据。我们已经在放射肿瘤学和支持性护理诊所中对埃德蒙顿症状评估量表(ESAS)进行了广泛研究。我们有兴趣研究 ESAS 数据是否与贫血相关。
自 2015 年以来,我们的诊所一直使用改良的 ESAS;现在患者使用平板电脑界面直接将数据输入电子病历。在提供 ESAS 报告的 9813 名患者中,我们从 8304 名患者中检索了血红蛋白(Hb)数据。其中,有 1351 名患者在同一天进行了这两项检查。如果 Hb 男性<13.0g/L 或女性<12.0g/L,则存在贫血。
当自我报告的疲倦和呼吸急促评分均为 7 分及以上时,贫血的阳性预测值(PPV)为 80%,特异性为 97.6%。相应的敏感性为 8.2%,准确性为 48.9%。这种两项目模型可能是一种有用的筛查工具,可以在门诊环境中筛查癌症患者是否存在贫血:如果患者对这两个 ESAS 项目的评分均<7,则存在<3%的假阳性风险。添加缺乏食欲、疼痛和骨髓原发病灶的扩展 5 项模型增加了敏感性和准确性,但牺牲了特异性和 PPV。我们认为这种方法不如两项目筛查更具临床功能。
这是首次报告使用 PRO 数据筛查临床体征(在此情况下为贫血)的报告之一。使用 2 个 ESAS 调查问题预测无贫血是可行的:疲倦和呼吸急促。