Department of Communicative Sciences and Disorders, New York University, 665 Broadway, Suite 900, New York, New York 10012, USA.
Department of Applied Statistics, Social Science, and Humanities, New York University, 246 Greene Street, 3rd Floor, New York, New York 10003, USA.
J Acoust Soc Am. 2019 Dec;146(6):4625. doi: 10.1121/1.5139423.
While recent research suggests that visual biofeedback can facilitate speech production training in clinical populations and second language (L2) learners, individual learners' responsiveness to biofeedback is highly variable. This study investigated the hypothesis that the type of biofeedback provided, visual-acoustic versus ultrasound, could interact with individuals' acuity in auditory and somatosensory domains. Specifically, it was hypothesized that learners with lower acuity in a sensory domain would show greater learning in response to biofeedback targeting that domain. Production variability and phonological awareness were also investigated as predictors. Sixty female native speakers of English received 30 min of training, randomly assigned to feature visual-acoustic or ultrasound biofeedback, for each of two Mandarin vowels. On average, participants showed a moderate magnitude of improvement (decrease in Euclidean distance from a native-speaker target) across both vowels and biofeedback conditions. The hypothesis of an interaction between sensory acuity and biofeedback type was not supported, but phonological awareness and production variability were predictive of learning gains, consistent with previous research. Specifically, high phonological awareness and low production variability post-training were associated with better outcomes, although these effects were mediated by vowel target. This line of research could have implications for personalized learning in both L2 pedagogy and clinical practice.
虽然最近的研究表明,视觉生物反馈可以促进临床人群和第二语言(L2)学习者的言语产生训练,但个体学习者对生物反馈的反应具有高度的可变性。本研究假设提供的生物反馈类型(视听与超声)与个体在听觉和体感领域的敏锐度有关。具体而言,假设在某个感觉领域敏锐度较低的学习者,对针对该领域的生物反馈会表现出更大的学习效果。还研究了发音变化和语音意识作为预测指标。60 名母语为英语的女性被试者接受了 30 分钟的训练,随机分配到具有视听或超声生物反馈的两种普通话元音。平均而言,参与者在两个元音和生物反馈条件下都表现出了中等程度的提高(从母语者目标的欧几里得距离减小)。感觉敏锐度和生物反馈类型之间的相互作用的假设没有得到支持,但语音意识和发音变化可以预测学习效果,这与之前的研究一致。具体而言,高语音意识和低发音变化与更好的结果相关,尽管这些影响受到目标元音的调节。这一系列研究可能对 L2 教学和临床实践中的个性化学习具有重要意义。