Division of Vascular Surgery, University of Florida, Gainesville, Fla.
Division of Vascular Surgery, University of Florida, Gainesville, Fla.
J Vasc Surg. 2020 Jul;72(1):92-104. doi: 10.1016/j.jvs.2019.09.049. Epub 2020 Jan 21.
Spinal cord ischemia (SCI) is a dreaded complication of thoracic endovascular aortic repair (TEVAR). There are limited national data describing the incidence and influence of in-hospital SCI recovery on survival. Moreover, no robust preoperative SCI risk assessment models currently exist. The purpose of this analysis was to analyze the Vascular Quality Initiative to determine the national incidence, survival association, and preoperative predictors of SCI after TEVAR.
All Vascular Quality Initiative TEVAR procedures (June 2014-June 2019) were reviewed. The primary end point was development of in-hospital SCI, defined as any new neurologic deficit or paralysis not attributable to intracranial disease. Secondary end points were disease-specific SCI rates and long-term out-of-hospital survival. Functional outcomes (transient vs permanent SCI) were independently determined by treating physicians. Kaplan-Meier analysis and Cox proportional hazards methodology were used to assess the association of SCI with survival. A logistic regression model of candidate preoperative SCI predictors was created, and bootstrapped backward elimination (retaining predictors with ≥50% selection frequency) was used for model reduction. Model fit and performance statistics were validated by adjustment for Efron's optimism.
The overall rate of SCI was 3.7% (n = 422/11,473; transient, 1.6% [n = 179]; permanent, 2.1% [n = 243]). Patients who developed any SCI had significantly lower Kaplan-Meier survival estimate compared with those without SCI (1-year survival: SCI, 65%; no SCI, 87%; P < .0001), and patients with permanent SCI had notably worse survival than patients with transient SCI (1-year survival: permanent SCI, 54%; transient SCI, 80%; P < .0001). Disease-specific incidence of any SCI was as follows: aneurysm, 3.4%; dissection, 5.3%; aneurysm from dissection, 4.1%; trauma, 1.1%; penetrating ulceration, 2.4%; intramural hematoma, 5.7%; penetrating ulceration and intramural hematoma, 4.3%; and aortic thrombus, 4.8%. Several factors were selected on multivariable analysis as the most robust preoperative predictors of any SCI, including distal landing zone 5 to zone 10, nonelective case, creatinine concentration >1.38 mg/dL, smoking history, American Society of Anesthesiologists class, adjunctive procedure, nonwhite race, and preoperative hypertension (area under the curve = 0.72; Nagelkerke R = 0.06).
SCI is a devastating complication after TEVAR that is associated with worse overall survival, particularly when no functional recovery occurs by hospital discharge. Disease-specific, real-world benchmarks for SCI rates are provided that may inform quality initiatives focused on reducing this complication. Importantly, this analysis is the first description of a preoperative prediction model derived from national data for determining SCI risk after TEVAR. These predictors should be used to identify high-risk patients to balance the risk of SCI and its associated increased short-term mortality with the risk of the underlying disease. Furthermore, all available adjunctive measures should be implemented in these high-risk patients to reduce risk of SCI.
脊髓缺血(SCI)是胸主动脉腔内修复术(TEVAR)的一种可怕并发症。目前,国内关于 SCI 发生率以及住院期间 SCI 恢复对生存率的影响的资料有限。此外,目前还没有可靠的术前 SCI 风险评估模型。本分析的目的是通过分析血管质量倡议(Vascular Quality Initiative)来确定全国范围内 TEVAR 后 SCI 的发生率、生存率关联和术前预测因素。
回顾所有血管质量倡议 TEVAR 手术(2014 年 6 月至 2019 年 6 月)。主要终点是院内 SCI 的发生,定义为任何新的神经功能缺损或不可归因于颅内疾病的瘫痪。次要终点是特定疾病的 SCI 发生率和长期院外生存率。功能结果(暂时性与永久性 SCI)由治疗医生独立确定。Kaplan-Meier 分析和 Cox 比例风险方法用于评估 SCI 与生存率的关联。创建了一个用于候选术前 SCI 预测因素的逻辑回归模型,并进行了 bootstrap 向后消除(保留≥50%选择频率的预测因素)来进行模型简化。通过 Efron 的乐观调整来验证模型拟合度和性能统计数据。
SCI 的总体发生率为 3.7%(n=422/11473;暂时性 SCI,1.6%[n=179];永久性 SCI,2.1%[n=243])。发生任何 SCI 的患者与无 SCI 的患者相比,Kaplan-Meier 生存率明显较低(1 年生存率:SCI,65%;无 SCI,87%;P<0.0001),且永久性 SCI 患者的生存率明显低于暂时性 SCI 患者(1 年生存率:永久性 SCI,54%;暂时性 SCI,80%;P<0.0001)。特定疾病的任何 SCI 发生率如下:动脉瘤,3.4%;夹层,5.3%;夹层动脉瘤,4.1%;创伤,1.1%;穿透性溃疡,2.4%;壁内血肿,5.7%;穿透性溃疡和壁内血肿,4.3%;主动脉血栓,4.8%。多变量分析选择了几个因素作为任何 SCI 的最有力术前预测因素,包括远端着陆区 5 区至 10 区、非择期病例、肌酐浓度>1.38mg/dL、吸烟史、美国麻醉医师协会(American Society of Anesthesiologists)分级、辅助手术、非白人种族和术前高血压(曲线下面积=0.72;Nagelkerke R=0.06)。
SCI 是 TEVAR 后一种严重的并发症,与总体生存率较差相关,尤其是在出院时无功能恢复时。提供了特定疾病的 SCI 发生率真实世界基准,这可能为旨在降低该并发症的质量倡议提供信息。重要的是,本分析首次描述了一种源自全国数据的用于确定 TEVAR 后 SCI 风险的术前预测模型。这些预测因素应被用于识别高危患者,以平衡 SCI 及其相关短期死亡率增加的风险与基础疾病的风险。此外,应在这些高危患者中实施所有可用的辅助措施,以降低 SCI 的风险。