Division of Cardiology, Department of Paediatrics, Hospital for Sick Children, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada; Division of Cardiovascular Surgery, Department of Surgery, Hospital for Sick Children, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Division of Pediatric Cardiac Surgical Centre, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences and Peking Union Medical College Fuwai Hospital, Beijing, China.
J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2020 Oct;160(4):1035-1042. doi: 10.1016/j.jtcvs.2019.11.123. Epub 2019 Dec 20.
OBJECTIVE: Data supporting the use of hands-on simulation in congenital heart surgery are promising but primarily qualitative. This study aimed to demonstrate if there was an objective improvement in time and technical performance of the arterial switch procedure on 3-dimensional printed heart models by surgeons using a validated assessment method. METHODS: A total of 30 surgeons of varying experience performed the arterial switch procedure twice on 3-dimensional printed models with transposition of the great arteries during the Hands-on Surgical Training courses. Surgeons' performances were recorded and retrospectively assessed for both time and performance using the Hands-on Surgical Training-Congenital Heart Surgery tool, a validated procedure-specific assessment tool for the arterial switch. RESULTS: A total of 60 videos were scored. Eighty percent of surgeons (24/30) had improved from their first attempt. The mean total score of the first attempt performance compared with the second was 103 and 120, respectively, with a mean difference in score of 17 (95% confidence interval, 10-24). All surgeons were statistically significantly quicker in their second attempt. The mean time for the first attempt compared with the second was 1 hour, 28 minutes, 4 seconds and 1 hour, 5 minutes, and 45 seconds, respectively, with a mean difference of 0 hours, 22 minutes, 19 seconds (95% confidence interval, 0 hours, 15 minutes, 22 seconds to 0 hours, 25 minutes, 34 seconds). CONCLUSIONS: This is the first study to demonstrate an objective improvement in time and technical performance of the arterial switch procedure on 3-dimensional printed heart models. This supports the evidence that simulation in the form of deliberate practice with constructive, objective feedback is fundamental in the training of future congenital heart surgeons. These simulations and assessments should be incorporated to create structured, standardized training curricula within congenital heart surgery.
目的:支持在先天性心脏病外科中使用实践模拟的证据虽然很有前景,但主要是定性的。本研究旨在通过使用经过验证的评估方法,证明在使用 3 维打印心脏模型进行动脉调转手术时,外科医生的时间和技术表现是否有客观的提高。
方法:共有 30 名不同经验水平的外科医生在“实践外科培训课程”中两次对 3 维打印的大动脉转位模型进行动脉调转手术。使用“实践外科培训-先天性心脏病外科工具”记录外科医生的表现,并对两次手术的时间和表现进行回顾性评估,该工具是动脉调转的一种经过验证的特定程序评估工具。
结果:共对 60 个视频进行了评分。80%的外科医生(24/30)在第一次尝试时有所提高。第一次尝试的总得分与第二次尝试的平均总得分分别为 103 和 120,得分差为 17(95%置信区间,10-24)。所有外科医生在第二次尝试时都明显更快。第一次尝试的平均时间与第二次尝试的平均时间分别为 1 小时 28 分钟 4 秒和 1 小时 5 分钟 45 秒,平均差异为 0 小时 22 分钟 19 秒(95%置信区间,0 小时 15 分钟 22 秒至 0 小时 25 分钟 34 秒)。
结论:这是第一项证明在 3 维打印心脏模型上进行动脉调转手术的时间和技术表现有客观提高的研究。这支持了这样的证据,即通过刻意练习、建设性和客观反馈的形式进行模拟,对于未来先天性心脏病外科医生的培训至关重要。这些模拟和评估应该被纳入到先天性心脏病外科的结构化、标准化培训课程中。
J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2019-12-24
J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2017-2-9
Semin Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2019-6-17
World J Pediatr Congenit Heart Surg. 2024-5
Ann Thorac Surg. 2017-12-21
Arq Bras Cardiol. 2025-2-10
World J Pediatr Congenit Heart Surg. 2024-5
3D Print Addit Manuf. 2023-10-1
Children (Basel). 2023-2-7
J Korean Med Sci. 2022-10-3