Department of Psychology, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada.
School of Social Work, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada.
Health Soc Care Community. 2020 Jul;28(4):1160-1169. doi: 10.1111/hsc.12948. Epub 2020 Jan 26.
Hoarded homes can pose a threat to public safety, with heightened risks of fire hazards, pest infestations and noxious odours in both the home and neighbouring dwellings. Communities across North America are responding to these public safety concerns through a harm reduction approach. This descriptive study explores the implementation and outcomes of the City of Vancouver's approach involving a partnership between fire prevention and public health. Data were collected from the team's 2016-2018 case tracking systems, consisting of health records and team intervention record, as well as notes taken from case briefing meetings. Study objectives included describing the intervention model, providing descriptive statistics on clients and their clutter volume, the interventions undertaken, and exploring predictors of clutter volume and case outcome through exploratory analyses. The sample included 82 cases involving severely hoarded conditions or more moderate hoarding conditions paired with additional client vulnerabilities (e.g. health conditions, frailty). Results from paired samples t-tests and regression analysis, suggest the Hoarding Action Response Team's (HART) model of a community-based intervention for hoarding was associated with clutter reduction and tenancy preservation. HART successfully maintained engagement with most clients, and most cases were closed within six home visits. Despite these successes, the team dealt with several barriers including client avoidance and limited resources. This paper provides guidance for communities who are working to develop a coordinated response to problems associated with hoarding and begins to establish expectations for what can be achieved through a community-based hoarding intervention model.
囤积的房屋可能对公共安全构成威胁,房屋和附近住宅都存在火灾隐患、虫害滋生和恶臭的风险。北美各地的社区正在通过减少伤害的方法来应对这些公共安全问题。这项描述性研究探讨了温哥华市通过消防和公共卫生合作的方式实施和取得的成果。数据来自该团队 2016-2018 年的案例跟踪系统,其中包括健康记录和团队干预记录,以及案例简报会议的记录。研究目的包括描述干预模型,提供客户及其杂物量的描述性统计数据、所进行的干预措施,并通过探索性分析探讨杂物量和案例结果的预测因素。该样本包括 82 例严重囤积或与其他客户脆弱性(如健康状况、脆弱性)相关的中度囤积情况。配对样本 t 检验和回归分析的结果表明,囤积行为反应小组(HART)的社区干预模式与杂物减少和租赁保留有关。HART 成功地与大多数客户保持了联系,并且大多数案例在六次家访内结案。尽管取得了这些成功,但该团队还是遇到了一些障碍,包括客户回避和资源有限。本文为正在努力制定协调一致的措施来应对与囤积相关问题的社区提供了指导,并开始为通过基于社区的囤积干预模型可以实现的目标建立预期。