Mayhew T M
Department of Anatomy, Marischal College, University of Aberdeen, Scotland.
J Anat. 1988 Apr;157:127-34.
Biopsies were made on six rat tibial nerves and 'absolute' numbers of myelinated fibres determined by counting all fibres in all nerve trunks. Subsequently, two unbiased sampling schemes-systematic random quadrat (SRQ) and 'fractionator' sampling-were used to select fibres from the same nerves and to obtain estimates of their numbers. Both schemes captured roughly 200 out of the total of 3000 myelinated fibres found in these nerve trunks, all of which were sampled exhaustively, without replacement. Estimates of fibre number were derived by an established approach, the 'ratio technique' (using SRQ samples), and by a new principle, the fractionator (using fractionator samples). Counting all fibres in every nerve trunk took almost 6 hours. Both the ratio technique and the fractionator approaches provided efficient and unbiased estimates of fibre numbers. Six nerve trunks were analysed by SRQ sampling in 77 minutes, compared with 65 minutes by the fractionator. Apparent differences between the two approaches were of minor interest when set against the benefits of sampling per se. These findings are likely to be of practical concern to those wishing to examine nerves with great numbers of fibres and/or to examine large numbers of nerves.
对六只大鼠的胫神经进行活检,并通过计数所有神经干中的所有纤维来确定有髓纤维的“绝对”数量。随后,使用两种无偏抽样方案——系统随机方格(SRQ)抽样和“分样器”抽样,从相同的神经中选择纤维并估计其数量。这两种方案在这些神经干中总共3000根有髓纤维中大致捕获了200根,所有这些纤维都被彻底抽样,且无放回。纤维数量的估计是通过一种既定方法“比率技术”(使用SRQ样本)和一种新原理“分样器”(使用分样器样本)得出的。对每个神经干中的所有纤维进行计数花费了近6小时。比率技术和分样器方法都提供了有效且无偏的纤维数量估计。通过SRQ抽样对六个神经干进行分析用时77分钟,而分样器用时65分钟。与抽样本身的益处相比,这两种方法之间的明显差异并不重要。这些发现可能会引起那些希望检查含有大量纤维的神经和/或检查大量神经的人的实际关注。