Evolution Génome Comportement et Ecologie, CNRS, IRD, Université Paris-Sud, Université Paris-Saclay, Gif-sur-Yvette, 91190, Paris, France.
Biochimie et Toxicologie des Substances Bioactives (BTSB), EA7417 Université de Toulouse, INU Champollion, 81000, Albi, France.
J Environ Manage. 2020 Mar 1;257:109983. doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2019.109983. Epub 2019 Dec 24.
Stakeholders are critical environmental managers in human-dominated landscapes. In some contexts, stakeholders can be forced to personally act following their own observations and risk perception instead of science recommendation. In particular, biological invasions need rapid control actions to reduce potential socio-ecological impacts, while science-based risk assessments are rather complex and time-delayed. Although they can lead to important detrimental effects on biodiversity, potential time-delayed disconnections between stakeholders' action and science recommendations are rarely studied. Using the case study of western European beekeepers controlling the invasive Asian hornet Vespa velutina nigrithorax for its suspected impact on honey bee colonies, we analysed mechanisms underlying personal actions of stakeholders and how they evolved in science disconnection. Personal actions of stakeholders were causal-effect linked with their risk observation but disconnected to time-delayed science predictions and recommendations. Unfortunately, these science-disconnected actions also led to dramatic impacts on numerous species of the local entomofauna. These results highlight the need to improve mutual risk communication between science and action in the early-stages of management plans to improve the sustainably of stakeholders' practices.
利益相关者是人类主导景观中的重要环境管理者。在某些情况下,利益相关者可能会被迫根据自己的观察和风险感知来采取行动,而不是遵循科学建议。特别是生物入侵需要采取快速控制措施,以减少潜在的社会生态影响,而基于科学的风险评估则比较复杂且耗时。尽管这些入侵行为可能对生物多样性产生重要的不利影响,但利益相关者的行动与科学建议之间潜在的时间延迟脱节很少被研究。本研究以西欧养蜂人控制亚洲大黄蜂 Vespa velutina nigrithorax 为例,分析了利益相关者个人行动的背后机制,以及它们如何在科学脱节中演变。利益相关者的个人行动与他们的风险观察有因果关系,但与时间延迟的科学预测和建议脱节。不幸的是,这些与科学脱节的行动也对当地昆虫区系的许多物种产生了巨大影响。这些结果强调了需要在管理计划的早期阶段加强科学与行动之间的风险沟通,以提高利益相关者实践的可持续性。