Centre for Rheumatic Diseases, Kings College London, LondonUK.
MRC Lifecourse Epidemiology Unit, University of Southampton, Southampton, UK.
Rheumatology (Oxford). 2020 Sep 1;59(9):2563-2571. doi: 10.1093/rheumatology/kez671.
To evaluate drug survival with monotherapy compared with combination therapy with MTX in RA older adults.
Patients from the British Society for Rheumatology Biologics Register, a prospective observational cohort, who were biologic naïve and commencing their first TNF inhibitors (TNFi) were included. The cohort was stratified according to age: <75 and ≥75. Cox-proportional hazards models compared the risk of TNFi discontinuation from (i) any-cause, (ii) inefficacy and (iii) adverse events, between patients prescribed TNFi-monotherapy compared with TNFi MTX combination.
The analysis included 15 700 patients. Ninety-five percent were <75 years old. Comorbidity burden and disease activity were higher in the ≥75 cohort. Fifty-two percent of patients discontinued TNFi therapy during the follow-up period. Persistence with therapy was higher in the <75 cohort. Patients receiving TNFi monotherapy were more likely to discontinue compared with patients receiving concomitant MTX [hazard rate 1.12 (1.06-1.18) P <0.001]. This finding only held true in patients <75 [hazard rate (HR) 1.11 (1.05-1.17) vs ≥75 [HR 1.13 (0.90-1.41)]. Examining TNFi discontinuation by cause revealed patients ≥75 receiving TNFi monotherapy were less likely to discontinue TNFi due to inefficacy [HR 0.66 (0.43-0.99) P=0.04] and more likely to discontinue therapy from adverse events [HR 1.41(1.02-1.96) P =0.04]. These results were supported by the multivariate adjustment in complete case and imputed analyses.
TNFi monotherapy is associated with increased treatment failure. In older adults, the disadvantage of TNFi monotherapy on drug survival is no longer seen. Patients ≥75 have fewer discontinuations due to inefficacy than adverse events compared with younger patients. This likely reflects greater disposition to toxicity but perhaps also a decline in immunogenicity associated with immunosenescence.
评估与 MTX 联合治疗相比,单药治疗在老年 RA 患者中的药物生存情况。
纳入了来自英国风湿病学会生物制剂登记处的前瞻性观察队列中的生物初治且开始首次使用 TNF 抑制剂(TNFi)的患者。该队列根据年龄分层:<75 岁和≥75 岁。Cox 比例风险模型比较了与 MTX 联合治疗相比,接受 TNFi 单药治疗的患者在(i)任何原因、(ii)无效和(iii)不良事件导致的 TNFi 停药风险。
分析纳入了 15700 名患者。95%的患者年龄<75 岁。≥75 岁组的合并症负担和疾病活动度更高。52%的患者在随访期间停止了 TNFi 治疗。<75 岁组的治疗持续时间更高。与接受 MTX 联合治疗的患者相比,接受 TNFi 单药治疗的患者更有可能停药[风险比(HR)1.12(1.06-1.18)P<0.001]。这一发现仅适用于<75 岁的患者[HR 1.11(1.05-1.17)vs ≥75 岁的患者[HR 1.13(0.90-1.41)]。根据停药原因检查发现,接受 TNFi 单药治疗的≥75 岁患者因无效而停药的可能性较小[HR 0.66(0.43-0.99)P=0.04],因不良事件停药的可能性更大[HR 1.41(1.02-1.96)P=0.04]。这些结果在完全病例和推断分析的多变量调整中得到了支持。
TNFi 单药治疗与治疗失败风险增加相关。在老年患者中,TNFi 单药治疗对药物生存的不利影响不再存在。与年轻患者相比,≥75 岁的患者因无效而停药的次数更少,因不良事件而停药的次数更多。这可能反映了更大的毒性倾向,但也可能反映了与免疫衰老相关的免疫原性下降。