Inconsistencies in paranoid functioning, premorbid adjustment, and chronicity: question of diagnostic criteria.

Despite the widely held belief that paranoid behavior is associated with good premorbid adjustment, low chronicity, and high current functioning in psychiatric inpatients, inconsistencies in the literature suggest that supportive evidence may be an artifact of the measurement model commonly used to index paranoid status. In a sample of 497 nonorganic inpatients selected from 19 treatment units, paranoid behavior, when measured by a dimensional/cumulative model, was not found to indicate higher functioning and associated relationships, but simply to reflect a narrower class of problem behavior. Only when paranoid status was defined using a traditional model based on the predominance of the defining class of behavior did paranoid subjects demonstrate better premorbid adjustment, lower chronicity, and higher levels of functioning than nonparanoid subjects. Serious problems exist in the use of information obtained from traditional predominance/class models for either theoretical or practical purposes.