Samudyatha U C, Chaudhari Vipul, Chauhan Naresh, Damor Rahul, Kosambiya J K, Munshi Rikita
Department of Community Medicine, Government Medical College, Surat, Gujarat, India.
Indian J Community Med. 2020 Jan-Mar;45(1):36-42. doi: 10.4103/ijcm.IJCM_180_19.
Clinical and epidemiological variables in the modified Faine's criteria offered low validity in our study setting.
Restructuring and validating modified Faine's criteria for leptospirosis to better suit health scenario of south Gujarat.
Clinical, epidemiological, and laboratory features of derivation cohort (1216 suspected leptospirosis cases) admitted at a tertiary care hospital of south Gujarat (2007-2015) that significantly correlated with confirmed leptospirosis were used in binary logistic regression to derive scoring models and receiver operating characteristic to determine cutoff values. Validity and net reclassification improvement (NRI) were estimated in validation cohort (82 cases, 2016-2017) and algorithm for diagnosis was prepared.
Screening model consisted of the presence of conjunctival suffusion, calf tenderness, raised serum creatinine, headache with conjunctival suffusion and/or jaundice, and dyspnea/meningism. Area under curve (AUC) for screening model was 0.590 (standard error [SE] ±0.017) and cutoff score ≥9 gave sensitivity 79.16%, specificity 50%. The confirmatory model consisted of laboratory parameters, namely polymerase chain reaction, immunoglobulin M ELISA, and microscopic agglutination test and gave AUC 0.998 (SE ± 0.001), sensitivity 89.58%, specificity 85.29%, positive predictive value 89.58%, and negative predictive value 85.29% at cutoff score ≥100. Net sensitivity of algorithm was 98.27% at the point of screening (screening model and rapid test) and net specificity 87.89% at the point of confirmation (screening followed by confirmatory model) in validation cohort.
Simultaneous use of screening model and rapid test gave NRI 81.25% and sequential use of confirmatory test gave NRI 47.18% compared to corresponding parts of the modified Faine's criteria.
在我们的研究环境中,改良费内标准中的临床和流行病学变量有效性较低。
重新构建并验证用于钩端螺旋体病的改良费内标准,以更好地适用于古吉拉特邦南部的健康状况。
在古吉拉特邦南部一家三级护理医院(2007 - 2015年)收治的推导队列(1216例疑似钩端螺旋体病病例)的临床、流行病学和实验室特征,这些特征与确诊的钩端螺旋体病显著相关,用于二元逻辑回归以推导评分模型和受试者工作特征曲线来确定临界值。在验证队列(82例,2016 - 2017年)中估计有效性和净重新分类改善(NRI),并编制诊断算法。
筛查模型包括结膜充血、小腿压痛、血清肌酐升高、伴有结膜充血和/或黄疸的头痛以及呼吸困难/脑膜刺激征。筛查模型的曲线下面积(AUC)为0.590(标准误[SE]±0.017),临界评分≥9时敏感性为79.16%,特异性为50%。确认模型由实验室参数组成,即聚合酶链反应、免疫球蛋白M酶联免疫吸附测定和显微镜凝集试验,在临界评分≥100时AUC为0.998(SE±0.001),敏感性为89.58%,特异性为85.29%,阳性预测值为89.58%,阴性预测值为85.29%。在验证队列中,算法的净敏感性在筛查点(筛查模型和快速检测)为98.27%,在确认点(筛查后接确认模型)的净特异性为87.89%。
与改良费内标准的相应部分相比,同时使用筛查模型和快速检测的净重新分类改善为81.25%,序贯使用确认检测的净重新分类改善为47.18%。