Mwachui Mwanajaa Abdalla, Crump Lisa, Hartskeerl Rudy, Zinsstag Jakob, Hattendorf Jan
Department of Epidemiology and Public Health, Swiss Tropical and Public Health Institute, Basel, Switzerland; University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland.
Royal Tropical Institute (KIT), KIT Biomedical Research, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2015 Sep 17;9(9):e0003843. doi: 10.1371/journal.pntd.0003843. eCollection 2015.
Leptospirosis is one of the most widespread zoonotic diseases, which is of global medical and veterinary importance, and also a re-emerging infectious disease. The main tracks of transmission are known; however, the relative importance of each of the components and the respective environmental risk factors are unclear. We aimed to assess and specify quantitative evidence of environmental risks of leptospirosis transmission.
METHODS/FINDINGS: A database of pre-selected studies, with publication dates from 1970 until 2008, was provided by an expert group. The database has been updated until 2015 using a text mining algorithm. Study selection was based on stringent quality criteria. A descriptive data analysis was performed to calculate the medians of the log transformed odds ratios. From a selection of 2723 unique publications containing information on leptospirosis, 428 papers dealing with risk factors were identified. Of these, 53 fulfilled the quality criteria, allowing us to identify trends in different geo-climatic regions. Water associated exposures were, with few exceptions, associated with an increased leptospirosis risk. In resource poor countries, floods and rainfall were of particular importance, whereas recreational water activities were more relevant in developed countries. Rodents were associated with increased leptospirosis risk, but the variation among studies was high, which might be partly explained by differences in exposure definition. Livestock contact was commonly associated with increased risk; however, several studies found no association. The median odds ratios associated with dog and cat contacts were close to unity. Sanitation and behavioural risk factors were almost always strongly associated with leptospirosis, although their impact was rarely investigated in Europe or North America.
This review confirms the complex environmental transmission pathways of leptospirosis, as previously established. Although, floods appeared to be among the most important drivers on islands and in Asia, the consistent pattern observed for exposure to rodents and behavioural and sanitation related risk factors indicate potential areas for intervention.
钩端螺旋体病是最广泛传播的人畜共患病之一,具有全球医学和兽医学重要性,也是一种再度出现的传染病。其主要传播途径已知;然而,各组成部分的相对重要性以及相应的环境风险因素尚不清楚。我们旨在评估并明确钩端螺旋体病传播的环境风险的定量证据。
方法/结果:一个专家组提供了一个预先选定的研究数据库,其发表日期从1970年至2008年。该数据库已使用文本挖掘算法更新至2015年。研究选择基于严格的质量标准。进行了描述性数据分析以计算对数转换比值比的中位数。从2723篇包含钩端螺旋体病信息的独特出版物中,识别出428篇涉及风险因素的论文。其中,53篇符合质量标准,使我们能够确定不同地理气候区域的趋势。除少数例外情况外,与水相关的暴露与钩端螺旋体病风险增加相关。在资源匮乏国家,洪水和降雨尤为重要,而在发达国家,娱乐性水上活动则更为相关。啮齿动物与钩端螺旋体病风险增加相关,但研究间的差异很大,这可能部分归因于暴露定义的差异。与家畜接触通常与风险增加相关;然而,一些研究未发现关联。与狗和猫接触的中位数比值比接近1。卫生和行为风险因素几乎总是与钩端螺旋体病密切相关,尽管在欧洲或北美很少对其影响进行研究。
本综述证实了钩端螺旋体病复杂的环境传播途径,如先前所确定的。尽管洪水似乎是岛屿和亚洲最重要的驱动因素之一,但观察到的与啮齿动物接触以及与行为和卫生相关风险因素的一致模式表明了潜在的干预领域。