Mulcahy D, Keegan J, Crean P, Quyyumi A, Shapiro L, Wright C, Fox K
National Heart Hospital, London.
Br Heart J. 1988 Nov;60(5):417-23. doi: 10.1136/hrt.60.5.417.
One hundred and fifty unselected patients with documented coronary artery disease were studied to establish the frequency and characteristics of silent myocardial ischaemia. Patients underwent ambulatory ST segment monitoring off all routine antianginal treatment (total 6264 hours) and exercise testing (n = 146). Ninety one patients (61%) had a total of 598 episodes of significant ST segment change, of which 446 (75%) were asymptomatic. Twenty seven patients (18%) had only painless episodes; 14 (9%) patients only painful episodes; 50 patients (33%) had both painless and painful episodes. The mean number of ST segment changes per day was 2.58 (1.95 silent); however, 11 patients (7%) had 50% of all silent episodes, and 48 patients (32%) had 91% of all silent episodes. Fifty nine patients (39%) had no ST segment changes on ambulatory monitoring, and 73 patients (49%) had no evidence of silent ischaemia. Episodes of silent ischaemia occurred with a similar circadian distribution to that of painful ischaemia, predominantly between 0730 and 1930. There was a similar mean rise in heart rate at the onset of both silent and painful episodes of ischaemia. Silent ischaemia was significantly more frequent in patients with three vessel disease than in those with single vessel disease, and was also significantly related to both time to 1 mm ST depression and maximal exercise duration on exercise testing. There was a highly significant relation between the mean number and duration of episodes of silent ischaemia in patients with positive exercise tests when compared with those with negative tests. No episode of ventricular tachycardia was recorded in association with silent ischaemic change.
对150例确诊为冠心病的未经挑选的患者进行研究,以确定无症状心肌缺血的发生率和特征。患者在停用所有常规抗心绞痛治疗的情况下接受动态ST段监测(总计6264小时)和运动试验(n = 146)。91例患者(61%)共有598次显著ST段改变发作,其中446次(75%)无症状。27例患者(18%)仅有无痛发作;14例患者(9%)仅有疼痛发作;50例患者(33%)既有无痛发作也有疼痛发作。每天ST段改变的平均次数为2.58次(1.95次为无症状性);然而,11例患者(7%)出现了所有无症状发作的50%,48例患者(32%)出现了所有无症状发作的91%。59例患者(39%)在动态监测中无ST段改变,73例患者(49%)无无症状缺血的证据。无症状缺血发作的昼夜分布与疼痛性缺血相似,主要发生在07:30至19:30之间。无症状和疼痛性缺血发作开始时心率的平均升高相似。三支血管病变患者的无症状缺血明显比单支血管病变患者更频繁,并且与运动试验中出现1毫米ST段压低的时间和最大运动持续时间均显著相关。与运动试验阴性的患者相比,运动试验阳性的患者无症状缺血发作的平均次数和持续时间之间存在高度显著的相关性。未记录到与无症状缺血改变相关的室性心动过速发作。