Wang Y K, Wang Y C, Shan F, Tang L, Li Z Y, Ji J F
Department of Gastrointestinal Cancer Center, Ward I, Key Laboratory of Carcinogenesis and Translational Research (Ministry of Education), Peking University Caner Hospital & Institute, Beijing 100142, China.
Zhonghua Wei Chang Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2020 Feb 25;23(2):152-157. doi: 10.3760/cma.j.issn.1671-0274.2020.02.010.
To evaluate the accuracy of the clinical staging by comparing preoperative clinical stage and pathological stage in gastric cancer patients, and to explore the potential beneficial population of neoadjuvant chemotherapy for gastric cancer. We retrospectively collected the clinical data of consecutive patients with gastric cancer who met the inclusion criteria (gastric adenocarcinoma, undergoing laparoscopic or open D2 radical operation, definite cTNM and pTNM) for admission of the Gastrointestinal Center of Peking University Cancer Hospital from July 2013 to April 2019. Patients with the number of harvested lymph nodes less than 16, history of gastric operation or preoperative radiochemotherapy were excluded. Preoperative clinical stage was obtained from abdominal and pelvic enhanced CT by radiologists, and postoperative pathological stage was derived from postoperative pathology reports. The concordance rate between preoperative clinical stage and postoperative pathological stage, and the proportion of pathological stage I in patients with specific preoperative clinical TNM stage were analyzed and compared. The potential beneficial population of neoadjuvant chemotherapy were considered as pI < 5%. Relationship between clinical features and concordance rate of stage was further analysed. A total of 459 patients were included in the analysis, including 321 males and 138 females with mean age of 60 (23 to 85) years old. The concordance rate from T1 to T4 between preoperative clinical T staging and postoperative pathological T staging was 82.5% (33/40), 31.1% (28/90), 34.4% (62/180), and 55.0% (96/149), respectively. The concordance rate from N0 to N3 between preoperative clinical N staging and postoperative pathological N staging was 58.8% (134/228), 22.1% (19/86), 23.6% (26/110), and 54.3% (19/35), respectively. The sensitivity and specificity of abdominal enhanced CT in the diagnosis of lymph node metastasis were 64.5% (171/265) and 69.1% (134/194) respectively. The clinical stage of cT3/T4 patients with pathological stage I was 9.1% (30/329), and the sensitivity of corresponding pathological stage III was 94.8% (164/173), while the cT3/4+cN1-3 patients with pathological stage I stage was 1.4% (3/218), and the sensitivity of corresponding pathological phase III was 76.9% (133/173). Tumor location was associated with the concordance of cT/pT staging [gastroesophageal junction: 64 (56.6%), upper stomach: 9 (9/17), middle stomach: 31 (40.3%), lower stomach: 97 (39.9%), whole stomach: 4(4/9), χ(2)=9.845, =0.043]; the degree of tumor differentiation was associated with the concordance of cN/pN staging [poorly differentiated: 94 (42.3%), moderated differentiated: 92 (41.1%), well differentiated: 12 (12/13), χ(2)=13.261, =0.001], whose differences were statistically significant (all <0.05). Based on a single-center retrospective data from Peking University Cancer Hospital, we think that the potential beneficial population of neoadjuvant chemotherapy for gastric cancer are those clinically staged as cT3/4+N1-3.
通过比较胃癌患者术前临床分期与病理分期来评估临床分期的准确性,并探索胃癌新辅助化疗的潜在受益人群。我们回顾性收集了2013年7月至2019年4月北京大学肿瘤医院胃肠中心收治的符合纳入标准(胃腺癌、接受腹腔镜或开放D2根治手术、明确的cTNM和pTNM)的连续胃癌患者的临床资料。排除淋巴结清扫数目少于16枚、有胃部手术史或术前放化疗史的患者。术前临床分期由放射科医生通过腹部和盆腔增强CT获得,术后病理分期来自术后病理报告。分析并比较术前临床分期与术后病理分期的符合率,以及特定术前临床TNM分期患者中病理I期的比例。新辅助化疗的潜在受益人群被认为是pI<5%。进一步分析临床特征与分期符合率之间的关系。共有459例患者纳入分析,其中男性321例,女性138例,平均年龄60(23至85)岁。术前临床T分期与术后病理T分期从T1到T4的符合率分别为82.5%(33/40)、31.1%(28/90)、34.4%(62/180)和55.0%(96/149)。术前临床N分期与术后病理N分期从N0到N3的符合率分别为58.8%(134/228)、22.1%(19/86)、23.6%(26/110)和54.3%(19/35)。腹部增强CT诊断淋巴结转移的敏感度和特异度分别为64.5%(171/265)和69.1%(134/194)。病理I期的cT3/T4患者临床分期为9.1%(30/329),相应病理III期的敏感度为94.8%(164/173),而病理I期的cT3/4+cN1-3患者为1.4%(3/218),相应病理III期的敏感度为76.9%(133/173)。肿瘤位置与cT/pT分期的符合情况有关[胃食管交界部:64(56.6%),胃上部:9(9/17),胃中部:31(40.3%),胃下部:97(39.9%),全胃:4(4/9),χ(2)=9.845,=0.043];肿瘤分化程度与cN/pN分期的符合情况有关[低分化:94(42.3%),中分化:92(41.1%),高分化:12(12/13),χ(2)=13.261,=0.001],差异均有统计学意义(均<0.05)。基于北京大学肿瘤医院单中心回顾性数据,我们认为胃癌新辅助化疗的潜在受益人群是临床分期为cT3/4+N1-3的患者。