Orthopaedic Registrar, Department of Orthopaedics-, Nelson R Mandela School of Medicine, Department of Orthopaedics, Nelson R Mandela School of Medicine, UKZN.
Trauma-Critical Care surgeon, Head Clinical Department and Director/Chief Trauma Surgeon: IALCH Trauma Service and Trauma ICU, Department of Surgery, Nelson R Mandela School of Medicine, UKZN.
Injury. 2020 Apr;51(4):930-934. doi: 10.1016/j.injury.2020.02.061. Epub 2020 Feb 14.
Radiographic imaging remains a cornerstone of orthopaedic practice. Traditional control X-Rays are routinely requested after procedures. These X-rays may add little value in post-op evaluation of trauma ICU patients, in light of intra-operative screening already performed and reviewed, but has high potential morbidity risk.
The aim is to determine if patients undergoing extra-articular fracture fixation, with fluoroscopic image guidance, require any management change due to immediate check x-rays findings.
Electronic patient and imaging records from January 2015 to November 2019 at a Trauma-specific ICU at a Trauma Society of South Africa accredited, Level 1 Trauma Unit were reviewed retrospectively. All patients matching the inclusion criteria were evaluated to determine if there were any complications and changes in management after the check X-Rays.
There were 103 ICU patients identified with a mean age of 32 years (3 to 94). Fifty-seven percent had fluoroscopy images as well as post-operative check x-rays and 51.5% had only check X-rays. Only two cases needed revision surgery based on the control x-ray findings. The post-operative x-ray did not alter the management of 98.1% of our patients.
In this study, routine post-op check x-rays did not add significant additional information to warrant early additional surgical intervention especially in ICU patients with adequate intra-operative fluoroscopy images. This investigation should be ordered for individual patients based on clinical grounds. This will help minimize patient exposure to avoidable radiation, labour intensive transfers to the radiology department, and decrease investigations that have financial implications but with limited benefits.
影像学检查仍然是骨科实践的基石。传统的 X 射线影像通常在手术后常规进行。对于在创伤 ICU 接受手术的创伤患者,鉴于已经进行了术中筛查和评估,术后的 X 射线检查可能没有什么价值,但存在很高的潜在发病风险。
旨在确定在使用透视图像引导进行关节外骨折固定后,是否需要根据即时检查 X 射线结果改变患者的治疗方案。
回顾性分析了 2015 年 1 月至 2019 年 11 月在南非创伤学会认证的 1 级创伤单位的创伤 ICU 的电子患者和影像学记录。对符合纳入标准的所有患者进行评估,以确定在进行检查 X 射线后是否存在任何并发症和治疗方案的改变。
共确定了 103 例 ICU 患者,平均年龄为 32 岁(3-94 岁)。57%的患者有透视图像以及术后检查 X 射线,51.5%的患者只有检查 X 射线。仅根据控制 X 射线结果发现了两例需要进行修正手术的病例。术后 X 射线并未改变 98.1%的患者的治疗方案。
在这项研究中,术后常规检查 X 射线并没有提供有意义的额外信息,因此不需要早期进行额外的手术干预,尤其是对于在术中已经有充分透视图像的 ICU 患者。根据临床情况,应针对个别患者来安排此项检查。这将有助于减少患者接触不必要辐射的机会,避免因频繁转移到放射科进行检查而带来的劳动力浪费,同时减少那些虽然有一定效益但也有经济限制的检查。