Ferdous Md Ruknul, Di Baldassarre Giuliano, Brandimarte Luigia, Wesselink Anna
1Faculty of Social and Behavioural Sciences, University of Amsterdam, 1012 WX Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Department of Integrated Water Systems and Governance, IHE Delft Institute for Water Education, 2611 AX Delft, The Netherlands.
Reg Environ Change. 2020;20(1):5. doi: 10.1007/s10113-020-01600-1. Epub 2020 Feb 3.
Levees protect floodplain areas from frequent flooding, but they can paradoxically contribute to more severe flood losses. The construction or reinforcement of levees can attract more assets and people in flood-prone area, thereby increasing the potential flood damage when levees eventually fail. Moreover, structural protection measures can generate a sense of complacency, which can reduce preparedness, thereby increasing flood mortality rates. We explore these phenomena in the Jamuna River floodplain in Bangladesh. In this study area, different levels of flood protection have co-existed alongside each other since the 1960s, with a levee being constructed only on the right bank and its maintenance being assured only in certain places. Primary and secondary data on population density, human settlements, and flood fatalities were collected to carry out a comparative analysis of two urban areas and two rural areas with different flood protection levels. We found that the higher the level of flood protection, the higher the increase of population density over the past decades as well as the number of assets exposed to flooding. Our results also show that flood mortality rates associated with the 2017 flooding in Bangladesh were lower in the areas with lower protection level. This empirical analysis of the unintended consequences of structural flood protection is relevant for the making of sustainable policies of disaster risk reduction and adaptation to climate change in rapidly changing environments.
堤坝保护洪泛区免受频繁洪水侵袭,但自相矛盾的是,它们可能导致更严重的洪水损失。堤坝的建造或加固会吸引更多资产和人员进入易洪区,从而在堤坝最终决堤时增加潜在的洪水破坏。此外,结构性保护措施会产生一种自满情绪,这会降低防范意识,进而提高洪水死亡率。我们在孟加拉国的贾木纳河洪泛区探讨这些现象。在该研究区域,自20世纪60年代以来,不同程度的防洪措施一直并存,只在右岸修建了堤坝,且只在某些地方确保其维护。收集了关于人口密度、人类住区和洪水死亡人数的主要和次要数据,以对两个不同防洪水平的城市地区和两个农村地区进行比较分析。我们发现,防洪水平越高,过去几十年人口密度的增长以及遭受洪水的资产数量就越高。我们的结果还表明,在保护水平较低的地区,与2017年孟加拉国洪水相关的洪水死亡率较低。这种对结构性防洪意外后果的实证分析,对于在快速变化的环境中制定可持续的灾害风险减少和适应气候变化政策具有重要意义。