Department of Health Promotion, University of Nebraska Medical Center, Omaha, Nebraska, USA
University of California San Francisco (UCSF), San Francisco, California, USA.
BMJ Sex Reprod Health. 2020 Jul;46(3):177-183. doi: 10.1136/bmjsrh-2019-200456. Epub 2020 Feb 25.
Popular support for access to abortion and contraceptive services is often based on the idea that they will help women determine the trajectory of their life course. This study examined whether receiving versus being denied an abortion affects aspirational life goal setting and attainment 5 years later.
We compared women who sought and were denied an abortion because they were 3 weeks beyond the gestational limit ('Parenting-Turnaways') to those who received an abortion in the first trimester ('First-Trimesters'); received an abortion within 2 weeks of the facility's gestational limit ('Near-Limits'); and sought an abortion, were turned away and received an abortion elsewhere or placed their baby for adoption ('Non-Parenting-Turnaways'). We used mixed effects logistic regression analyses to estimate the odds of setting an aspirational plan and to estimate the odds of both setting and achieving an aspirational 5-year plan.
At 1 week post abortion-seeking, 791 women reported 1864 5-year plans, most of which were aspirational (n=1692, 91%). Parenting-Turnaways had lower odds of setting an aspirational 5-year plan than Near-Limits (OR 0.36, 95% CI 0.18 to 0.73). There were no differences by group in achieving aspirational 5-year plans among those who had them.
Soon after abortion-seeking, women denied a wanted abortion were less optimistic about their long-term futures than women who received a wanted abortion. Abortion access can help women set positive long-term goals.
人们普遍支持获得堕胎和避孕服务,其依据通常是认为这些服务将帮助女性决定其人生轨迹。本研究旨在探讨接受或拒绝堕胎是否会影响女性在 5 年后设定理想的人生目标并实现该目标。
我们将寻求并被拒绝堕胎的女性(因妊娠已超过 3 周而无法堕胎,称为“育儿型拒绝堕胎者”)与妊娠 12 周内堕胎的女性(称为“妊娠 12 周内堕胎者”)、妊娠 12 周内接近医院规定堕胎时间限制堕胎的女性(称为“接近堕胎时间限制者”)以及寻求堕胎、被拒绝堕胎并在其他地方堕胎或将婴儿送养的女性(称为“非育儿型拒绝堕胎者”)进行了比较。我们采用混合效应逻辑回归分析来估计设定理想计划的可能性,并估计设定和实现理想 5 年计划的可能性。
在寻求堕胎后 1 周,791 名女性报告了 1864 项 5 年计划,其中大多数是理想的(n=1692,91%)。与接近堕胎时间限制者相比,育儿型拒绝堕胎者设定理想的 5 年计划的可能性较低(OR 0.36,95%CI 0.18 至 0.73)。在那些设定了理想 5 年计划的女性中,不同组别在实现该计划方面没有差异。
在寻求堕胎后不久,被拒绝接受想要的堕胎的女性对自己的长期未来不如那些接受了想要的堕胎的女性乐观。堕胎机会可以帮助女性设定积极的长期目标。