University of Belgrade, Faculty of Sport and Physical Education, The Research Centre, Belgrade, Serbia.
Faculty of Health Science, Universidad Europea De Canarias, La Orotava, Spain.
J Sports Sci. 2020 Apr;38(7):759-766. doi: 10.1080/02640414.2020.1734299. Epub 2020 Feb 26.
This study aimed to compare the reliability and magnitude of velocity variables between 3 variants of the bench press (BP) exercise in participants with and without BP training experience. Thirty males, 15 with and 15 without BP experience, randomly performed 3 variants of the BP on separate sessions: (I) concentric-only, (II) fast-eccentric and (III) controlled-eccentric. The mean velocity (MV) and maximum velocity (V) of the concentric phase were collected against 3 loads (≈30%1RM, 50%1RM, and 75%1RM) with a linear velocity transducer. Reliability was high regardless of the variable, BP variant, and load (coefficient of variation [CV] ≤ 4.47%, intraclass correlation coefficient [ICC] ≥ 0.87). The comparison of the CVs suggested a higher reliability for the fast-eccentric BP (8 out of 12 comparisons), followed by the concentric-only BP (5 out of 12 comparisons), and finally the controlled-eccentric BP (never provided a higher reliability). No differences in reliability were observed between experienced (CV ≤ 4.71%; ICC ≥ 0.79) and non-experienced (CV ≤ 6.29%; ICC ≥ 0.76) participants. The fast-eccentric BP provided the highest MV ( < 0.05) and no differences were observed for V. These results support the assessment of movement velocity during the fast-eccentric BP even in participants without experience.
本研究旨在比较有和无卧推(BP)训练经验的参与者在 3 种 BP 变体中速度变量的可靠性和幅度。30 名男性,15 名有经验,15 名无经验,随机在 3 个不同的训练日进行 3 种 BP 变体:(I)仅向心,(II)快速离心和(III)控制离心。使用线性速度传感器收集 3 个负荷(≈30%1RM、50%1RM 和 75%1RM)下向心阶段的平均速度(MV)和最大速度(V)。无论变量、BP 变体和负荷如何,可靠性都很高(变异系数 [CV]≤4.47%,组内相关系数 [ICC]≥0.87)。比较 CV 表明,快速离心 BP 的可靠性更高(12 次比较中有 8 次),其次是仅向心 BP(12 次比较中有 5 次),最后是控制离心 BP(从未提供更高的可靠性)。有经验(CV≤4.71%;ICC≥0.79)和无经验(CV≤6.29%;ICC≥0.76)参与者之间的可靠性没有差异。快速离心 BP 提供了最高的 MV(<0.05),V 没有差异。这些结果支持在没有经验的参与者中评估快速离心 BP 期间的运动速度。