Rydzewska-Rosołowska Alicja, Jamiołkowska Milena, Kakareko Katarzyna, Naumnik Beata, Zbroch Edyta, Hryszko Tomasz
Department of Nephrology and Hypertension with Dialysis Unit, Medical University of Białystok, Białystok, Poland.
Department of Pediatrics, Endocrinology, Diabetology with Cardiology Divisions, Medical University of Białystok, Białystok, Poland.
Transplant Proc. 2020 Apr;52(3):695-699. doi: 10.1016/j.transproceed.2019.12.043. Epub 2020 Feb 28.
In the modern era, organ transplantation has become an important means of treating certain diseases. Although it is widespread and medically accepted, certain controversies still exist.
The aim of this study was to evaluate attitudes toward organ transplantation among medical students.
The anonymous survey was conducted among 273 medical students (from the departments of medicine, dentistry, nursing, and physiotherapy). The questionnaire was self-designed and contained 15 dichotomous questions.
Among students, 99.6% accepted transplantation as a therapeutic method. Live-donor transplantation was accepted by 98.9% of students and transplantation from unrelated donors by 92.6% and 87.6% (depending on the existence of an emotional bond between the donor and the recipient). Interestingly, 12.8% of students approved of the selling of organs as a means of expanding the donor pool, and there were significant differences between divisions. On average, 90.1% of students declared knowledge of the definition of brain death with statistically significant differences between groups. Unfortunately, only 81.3% of students accepted the definition of brain death. Moreover, 98.5% of students would accept an organ if needed but only 93.8% declared willingness to donate organs after death. Interestingly, 26.4% of subjects stated that family should decide whether organs can be retrieved. Only 69.2% of respondents had talked to loved ones about their attitudes concerning organ transplantation.
Although organ transplantation as a therapeutic method is widely accepted, there are still certain areas where considerable controversies exist. A structured, well-planned educational program should be implemented to improve awareness and attitude, especially among medical students.
在现代,器官移植已成为治疗某些疾病的重要手段。尽管它广泛应用且被医学所接受,但仍存在一些争议。
本研究旨在评估医学生对器官移植的态度。
对273名医学生(来自医学、牙科、护理和物理治疗专业)进行了匿名调查。问卷为自行设计,包含15个二分法问题。
在学生中,99.6%的人接受移植作为一种治疗方法。98.9%的学生接受活体捐赠移植,92.6%和87.6%的学生接受来自非亲属捐赠者的移植(取决于捐赠者与接受者之间是否存在情感联系)。有趣的是,12.8%的学生赞成出售器官以扩大捐赠库,不同专业之间存在显著差异。平均而言,90.1%的学生宣称了解脑死亡的定义,各群体之间存在统计学上的显著差异。不幸的是,只有81.3%的学生接受脑死亡的定义。此外,98.5%的学生在需要时会接受器官,但只有93.8%的学生宣称愿意在死后捐赠器官。有趣的是,26.4%的受试者表示应由家人决定是否可以摘取器官。只有69.2%的受访者与亲人谈论过他们对器官移植的态度。
尽管器官移植作为一种治疗方法被广泛接受,但仍有一些领域存在相当大的争议。应实施一个结构化、精心规划的教育项目,以提高认识和态度,特别是在医学生中。