Passaro Antonio, Mackenzie Graham, Lambertini Matteo, Morgan Gilberto, Zimmermann Stefan, Garrido Pilar, Curigliano Giuseppe, Trapani Dario
Division of Thoracic Oncology, European Institute of Oncology, IRCCS, Milan, Italy
NHS Education for Scotland, Edinburgh, UK.
ESMO Open. 2020 Feb;5(1). doi: 10.1136/esmoopen-2019-000598. Epub 2020 Feb 5.
Twitter is a microblogging service providing a platform for social networking. For medical information, Twitter is an interesting channel for sharing and spreading information and as an engagement platform for different stakeholders. Benefits and caveats of uncontrolled medical information must be carefully pondered, considering the possible intended and unintended adverse outcomes of uncontrolled influencing. The aim of this study was to describe the non-commercial content shared on Twitter and to analyse the level of influence of commercial tweeters during the European Society of Medical Oncology (ESMO) 2018 annual meeting held in Munich.
DESIGN/METHODOLOGY: A retrospective analysis of the tweets shared in the period 19-23 October 2018 indexed with the hashtag #ESMO18 or #ESMO2018 was performed; methodology of systematic reviews was mirrored. Commercial tweeters (pharmaceutical and biotechnology companies, device manufacturers and spam tweeters) were excluded from the primary analysis, and only non-commercial tweets from and about the congress were included. Tweets were analysed using a network analytical tool (NodeXL).
A total of 7100 tweets posted by 1334 tweeters were identified for the period of interest. Less than 10% of tweeters were identified as commercial, posting 15.7% of tweets and receiving almost one-quarter of retweets. However, pharmaceutical and biotech tweeters were substantially less likely to be mentioned by other tweeters. All of the top 10 retweeters of non-commercial content were clinicians and/or professional organisations, in stark contrast with the commercial content.
The use of social networks in medical meetings, including oncology, is increasing for real-time communication and informed opinion-making. The uncontrolled spread of information on Twitter can both stimulate discussions on non-official and non-canonical channels of communication and provide uncontrolled influencing of diverse stakeholders. The disclosure of financial declarations of interest on Twitter could enhance the transparency of the information, as is already happening in medical journals.
推特是一种微博服务,为社交网络提供了一个平台。对于医学信息而言,推特是分享和传播信息的一个有趣渠道,也是不同利益相关者的互动平台。必须仔细权衡不受控制的医学信息的益处和注意事项,考虑到不受控制的影响可能产生的有意和无意的不良后果。本研究的目的是描述在推特上分享的非商业内容,并分析在慕尼黑举行的2018年欧洲肿瘤内科学会(ESMO)年会期间商业推特用户的影响程度。
设计/方法:对2018年10月19日至23日期间使用#ESMO18或#ESMO2018标签索引的推文进行回顾性分析;采用系统评价的方法。商业推特用户(制药和生物技术公司、设备制造商和垃圾推特用户)被排除在主要分析之外,仅纳入来自大会和关于大会的非商业推文。使用网络分析工具(NodeXL)对推文进行分析。
在感兴趣的时间段内,共识别出1334名推特用户发布的7100条推文。不到10%的推特用户被认定为商业用户,他们发布了15.7%的推文,并获得了近四分之一的转发。然而,制药和生物技术推特用户被其他推特用户提及的可能性要小得多。非商业内容的前10大转发者均为临床医生和/或专业组织,这与商业内容形成鲜明对比。
在包括肿瘤学在内的医学会议中,社交网络用于实时交流和提供明智决策的情况正在增加。推特上信息的不受控制传播既可以激发在非官方和非规范交流渠道上的讨论,也会对不同利益相关者产生不受控制的影响。正如医学期刊中已经出现的情况那样,在推特上披露财务利益声明可以提高信息的透明度。