Department of Colorectal Surgery, Queen Alexandra Hospital, Portsmouth Hospitals NHS Trust, Portsmouth, UK.
University of Portsmouth, Portsmouth, UK.
Updates Surg. 2021 Jun;73(3):815-821. doi: 10.1007/s13304-020-00734-5. Epub 2020 Mar 7.
The swift endorsement of the robotic surgical platform indicates that it might prevail as the preferred technique for many complex abdominal and pelvic operations. Nonetheless, use of the surgical robotic system introduces further layers of complexity into the operating theatre necessitating new training models. Instructive videos with relevant exposition could be optimal for early training in robotic surgery and the aim of this study was to develop consensus guidelines on how to report a robotic surgery video for educational purposes to achieve high quality educational video outputs that could enhance surgical training. A steering group prepared a Delphi survey of 46 statements, which was distributed and voted on utilising an electronic survey tool. The selection of committee members was designed to include representative surgical trainers worldwide across different specialties, including lower and upper gastrointestinal surgery, general surgery, gynaecology and urology. 36 consensus statements were approved and classified in seven categories: author's information and video introduction, case presentation, demonstration of the surgical procedure, outcomes of the procedure, associated educational content, review of surgical videos quality and use of surgical videos in educational curricula. Consensus guidelines on how to report robotic surgery videos for educational purposes have been elaborated utilising Delphi methodology. We recommend that adherence to the guidelines presented could support advancing the educational quality of video outputs when designed for training.
该机器人手术平台得到迅速认可,这表明它可能成为许多复杂的腹部和骨盆手术的首选技术。然而,使用手术机器人系统会给手术室带来更多的复杂性,需要新的培训模式。带有相关讲解的教学视频可能是机器人手术早期培训的最佳选择,本研究旨在制定关于如何为教育目的报告机器人手术视频的共识指南,以获得高质量的教育视频输出,从而增强手术培训。一个指导小组准备了一份 46 个陈述的德尔菲调查,并利用电子调查工具进行了分发和投票。委员会成员的选择旨在包括来自不同专业的全球有代表性的外科培训师,包括下胃肠道手术、普通外科、妇科和泌尿科。36 个共识陈述得到了批准,并分为七个类别:作者信息和视频介绍、病例介绍、手术过程演示、手术过程结果、相关教育内容、手术视频质量审查以及手术视频在教育课程中的使用。本研究利用德尔菲法制定了用于教育目的的机器人手术视频报告的共识指南。我们建议,当为培训设计视频输出时,遵循这些指南可以支持提高视频输出的教育质量。