Faculty of Science, School of Life and Environmental Sciences, The University of Sydney, Sydney, New South Wales 2006, Australia.
Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 2020 Apr 27;375(1797):20190362. doi: 10.1098/rstb.2019.0362. Epub 2020 Mar 9.
The Price equation has been entangled with social evolution theory from the start. It has been used to derive the most general versions of kin selection theory, and Price himself produced a multilevel equation that provides an alternative formulation of social evolution theory, dividing selection into components between and within groups. In this sense, the Price equation forms a basis for both kin and group selection, so often pitted against each other in the literature. Contextual analysis and the neighbour approach are prominent alternatives for analysing group selection. I discuss these four approaches to social evolution theory and their connections to the Price equation, focusing on their similarities and common mathematical structure. Despite different notations and modelling traditions, all four approaches are ultimately linked by a common set of mathematical components, revealing their underlying unity in a transparent way. The Price equation can similarly be used in the derivation of streamlined, weak selection social evolution modelling methods. These weak selection models are practical and powerful methods for constructing models in evolutionary and behavioural ecology; they can clarify the causal structure of models, and can be easily converted between the four social evolution approaches just like their regression counterparts. This article is part of the theme issue 'Fifty years of the Price equation'.
从一开始,价格方程就与社会进化理论纠缠在一起。它被用来推导出最一般的亲缘选择理论版本,普赖斯本人还提出了一个多层次的方程,为社会进化理论提供了另一种表述方式,将选择划分为群体之间和群体内部的成分。从这个意义上说,价格方程是亲缘选择和群体选择的基础,因此在文献中经常相互对立。语境分析和邻居方法是分析群体选择的突出替代方法。我讨论了这四种社会进化理论方法及其与价格方程的联系,重点关注它们的相似之处和共同的数学结构。尽管有不同的符号和建模传统,但所有这四种方法最终都通过一组共同的数学成分联系在一起,以一种透明的方式揭示了它们的内在统一性。价格方程也可以用于推导出简化的、弱选择的社会进化建模方法。这些弱选择模型是进化和行为生态学中构建模型的实用而强大的方法;它们可以澄清模型的因果结构,并且可以像它们的回归对应物一样,在这四种社会进化方法之间轻松转换。本文是主题为“价格方程五十年”的一部分。