Welland Sarah, Duffy Linda J, Baluch Bahman
School of Science and Technology, Middlesex University, London, UK.
J Exerc Rehabil. 2020 Feb 26;16(1):78-87. doi: 10.12965/jer.1938726.363. eCollection 2020 Feb.
There is a growing body of research on the effectiveness of rehabilitation programs in a Young Offenders' Institution (YOI). The aim of the present study is to investigate the effectiveness of rugby training as a rehabilitation intervention in a YOI in the United Kingdom. Young adult males (n=46) currently serving sentences at the YOI were split into two groups, intervention (n=25; mean age, 19.64±0.81 years) and no intervention (n=21; mean age, 19.76±0.89). Participants completed the Criminal Attitudes and Associates (MCAA) instrument at three different time cycles and then pre/post for intervention group. Additionally, qualitative interviews (one to one and focus groups) were carried out with the intervention and no intervention groups during the same cycles of the study. The results of questionnaire analysis showed no significant difference in MCAA measures taken before and after rugby intervention. Interestingly, the intervention group showed more procriminal attitudes on their responses compared to the no intervention group. Finally, analysis of the 3 cycles of data collected showed that the time of the year the questionnaire was completed has a significant impact on the responses given. In contrast, the qualitative interviews showed a very positive change of attitude towards rehabilitation from the intervention group after rugby training. The implications of the results in relation to studies aimed at evaluation of the intervention programs in YOI are discussed.
关于青少年犯教养所(YOI)康复项目有效性的研究越来越多。本研究的目的是调查橄榄球训练作为一种康复干预措施在英国一所青少年犯教养所中的有效性。目前在该青少年犯教养所服刑的成年男性(n = 46)被分为两组,干预组(n = 25;平均年龄,19.64±0.81岁)和非干预组(n = 21;平均年龄,19.76±0.89)。参与者在三个不同的时间周期完成了《犯罪态度与同伴》(MCAA)工具的测试,干预组还进行了干预前/后的测试。此外,在研究的同一周期内,对干预组和非干预组进行了定性访谈(一对一访谈和焦点小组访谈)。问卷调查分析结果显示,橄榄球干预前后的MCAA测量结果没有显著差异。有趣的是,与非干预组相比,干预组在回答中表现出更多的亲犯罪态度。最后,对收集到的三个周期的数据进行分析表明,完成问卷的年份对给出的回答有显著影响。相比之下,定性访谈显示,橄榄球训练后干预组对康复的态度有非常积极的变化。讨论了这些结果对旨在评估青少年犯教养所干预项目的研究的意义。