Clinical Epidemiology Program, Ottawa Hospital Research Institute, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
Faculty of Medicine, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
Korean J Anesthesiol. 2021 Feb;74(1):6-14. doi: 10.4097/kja.19484. Epub 2020 Mar 13.
Sex and gender, among other equity-related characteristics, influence the process of care and patients' outcomes. Currently, the extent to which these characteristics are considered in the anesthesia literature remains unknown. This study assesses their incorporation in randomized controlled trials (RCTs) on anesthesia-related interventions, for both patients and healthcare providers. This is a cross-sectional analysis using an existing dataset derived from the anesthesia literature. The dataset originated from a scoping review searching MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL, CENTRAL, and the Cochrane Database of Systematic reviews. RCTs investigating the effect of anesthesia-related interventions on mortality for adults undergoing surgery were included. Equity outcome measures were recorded for both patients and providers and assessed for inclusion in the study design, reporting of results, and analysis of intervention effects. Three-hundred sixty-one RCTs (n = 144,674) were included. Most RCTs (91%) reported patient sex/gender, with 58% of patients identified as male. There were 139 studies (39%), where 70% or more of the sample was male, compared to just 14 studies (4%), where 70% or more of the sample was female. Only 10 studies (3%) analyzed results by patient sex/gender, with one reporting a significant effect. There was substantial variation in how age was reported, although nearly all studies (98%) reported some measure of age. For healthcare providers, equity-related information was never available. Better consideration of sex/gender and additional health equity parameters for both patients and providers in RCTs is needed to improve evidence quality, and ultimately, patient care and outcome.
性别和其他与公平相关的特征,会影响医疗过程和患者的结局。目前,这些特征在麻醉文献中被考虑的程度尚不清楚。本研究评估了它们在与麻醉相关的干预措施的随机对照试验(RCT)中对患者和医疗保健提供者的纳入程度。这是一项使用现有数据集的横断面分析,该数据集来源于对麻醉文献进行的范围综述。数据集源自对 MEDLINE、Embase、CINAHL、CENTRAL 和 Cochrane 系统评价数据库的搜索。纳入了调查与麻醉相关的干预措施对接受手术的成年人死亡率影响的 RCT。记录了患者和提供者的公平结局指标,并评估了其在研究设计、结果报告和干预效果分析中的纳入情况。共纳入 361 项 RCT(n=144674)。大多数 RCT(91%)报告了患者的性别,其中 58%的患者为男性。有 139 项研究(39%)中,70%或以上的样本为男性,而只有 14 项研究(4%)中,70%或以上的样本为女性。只有 10 项研究(3%)按患者性别分析了结果,其中一项报告了显著的效果。虽然几乎所有研究(98%)都报告了某种形式的年龄,但年龄的报告方式存在很大差异。对于医疗保健提供者,没有公平相关的信息。需要更好地考虑患者和提供者的性别/性别和其他健康公平参数,以提高 RCT 的证据质量,最终改善患者的护理和结局。