Banerjee N, Banerjee A, Sabde Y, Tiwari R R, Prakash A
ICMR-National Institute for Research in Environmental Health, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, India.
J Postgrad Med. 2020 Apr-Jun;66(2):73-80. doi: 10.4103/jpgm.JPGM_391_19.
A cross-sectional study was undertaken to assess the prevalence of morbidities in communities residing at variable distances from the closed down insecticide manufacturing plant premises of Union Carbide India Limited (UCIL), Bhopal, India and to determine association of morbidities, if any, with their drinking water usage pattern and distance of localities from the UCIL plant.
A total of 10,827 individuals belonging to 2,184 families, residing within 0-1 km (Stratum I) and 2.5-5.0 km (Stratum II) radial distances from UCIL plant were surveyed and 9,306 of them (86%) were clinically examined. Data were analyzed to examine the association between the groups of morbidities, likely due to biological and chemical water contamination, and the distance of locality from the UCIL plant. Multiple logistic regression was used to explore the risk factors for morbidities.
Nearly similar prevalence (25.3% in stratum I, 25.8% in stratum II) and the trend of all-cause morbidities were recorded in the two strata. While morbidities related to gastrointestinal tract system (P < 0.05), auditory system (P < 0.01), neoplasm/cancers (P < 0.01) and congenital anomalies (P < 0.01) were significantly higher in stratum I, the prevalence of hypertension (6.4% stratum II, 4.7% stratum I; P < 0.01) and diabetes mellitus (3.4% stratum II, 2.0% stratum I; P < 0.001) was found significantly higher in stratum II. No association (P > 0.05) was observed between the prevalence of morbidities, likely due to the consumption of biologically or chemically contaminated drinking water, and the distance of locality/stratum from the UCIL plant.
By and large similar pattern of morbidities were recorded in the two strata suggesting that the communities, irrespective of the distance of their residences from UCIL plant or sources of their drinking water, are equally vulnerable to various morbidities.
开展一项横断面研究,以评估居住在距印度博帕尔联合碳化物印度有限公司(UCIL)已关闭的杀虫剂制造厂不同距离的社区中疾病的患病率,并确定疾病(若存在)与其饮用水使用模式以及各地区距UCIL工厂距离之间的关联。
对总共2184个家庭的10827名个体进行了调查,这些个体居住在距UCIL工厂径向距离0至1公里(第一层)和2.5至5.0公里(第二层)范围内,其中9306人(86%)接受了临床检查。对数据进行分析,以检验可能因生物和化学水污染导致的疾病组与各地区距UCIL工厂距离之间的关联。采用多元逻辑回归来探究疾病的危险因素。
两层中记录的全因发病率患病率(第一层为25.3%,第二层为25.8%)及趋势几乎相似。虽然第一层中与胃肠道系统相关的疾病(P<0.05)、听觉系统疾病(P<0.01)、肿瘤/癌症(P<0.01)和先天性异常(P<0.01)的患病率显著更高,但发现第二层中高血压(第二层为6.4%,第一层为4.7%;P<0.01)和糖尿病(第二层为3.4%,第一层为2.0%;P<0.001)的患病率显著更高。未观察到可能因饮用生物或化学污染的饮用水导致的疾病患病率与各地区/层距UCIL工厂距离之间存在关联(P>0.05)。
两层中记录的疾病模式总体上相似,这表明这些社区,无论其住所距UCIL工厂的距离或饮用水来源如何,同样易患各种疾病。