J Dent Educ. 2020 Mar;84(3):316-322. doi: 10.21815/JDE.019.189.
Valid and reliable assessment of students' knowledge and skills is integral to dental education. However, most faculty members receive no formal training on student assessment techniques. The aim of this study was to quantify the value of a professional development program designed to improve the test item-writing skills of dental faculty members. A quasi-experimental (pretest, intervention, posttest) study was conducted with faculty members in the dental school of Majmaah University, Saudi Arabia. Data assessed were 450 multiple-choice questions (MCQs) from final exams in 15 courses in 2017 (prior to the intervention; pretest) and the same number in 2018 (after the intervention; posttest). The intervention was a faculty development program implemented in 2018 to improve the writing of MCQs. This training highlighted construct-irrelevant variance-the abnormal increase or decrease in test scores due to factors extraneous to constructs of interest-and provided expert advice to rectify flaws. Item analysis of pre- and post-intervention MCQs determined the difficulty index, discrimination index, and proportion of non-functional distractors for each question. MCQs on 2017 and 2018 exams were compared on each of these parameters. The results showed statistically significant improvements in MCQs from 2017 to 2018 on all parameters. MCQs with low discrimination decreased, those with high discrimination increased, and the proportion of questions with more than two non-functional distractors were reduced. These results provide evidence of improved test item quality following implementation of a long-term faculty development program. Additionally, the findings underscore the need for an active dental education department and demonstrate its value for dental schools.
对学生的知识和技能进行有效且可靠的评估是牙科教育的重要组成部分。然而,大多数教师并未接受过学生评估技术的正规培训。本研究旨在量化一项旨在提高牙科教师试题编写技能的专业发展计划的价值。本研究采用准实验(前测、干预、后测)设计,在沙特阿拉伯麦加大学牙科学院的教师中进行。评估的数据是 2017 年 15 门课程期末考试中的 450 道多项选择题(MCQ)(干预前;前测)和 2018 年相同数量的 MCQ(干预后;后测)。干预措施是 2018 年实施的一项教师发展计划,旨在提高 MCQ 的编写质量。该培训强调了与结构无关的方差-由于与感兴趣的结构无关的因素导致的考试成绩的异常增加或减少-并提供了纠正缺陷的专家建议。对干预前后的 MCQ 进行项目分析,确定每个问题的难度指数、区分指数和非功能干扰项的比例。比较了 2017 年和 2018 年考试的 MCQ 在这些参数上的差异。结果表明,2017 年至 2018 年,所有参数的 MCQ 均有显著提高。区分度低的 MCQ 减少,区分度高的 MCQ 增加,有两个以上非功能干扰项的问题比例减少。这些结果为实施长期教师发展计划后测试项目质量的提高提供了证据。此外,研究结果强调了积极的牙科教育部门的必要性,并展示了其对牙科学校的价值。